Maet said:
The way you go about posting is condescending. You'll make a thread/statement stating your opinion. Someone with a negative or opposite view point will respond, and you immediately reply holding an olive branch trying to reconcile the issue in a method that I find screams "I win because I maintain my view and respect yours too" (this would've been a good example if you hadn't asked for a rebuttal). You claim to seek discussion, but when I see anyone try to engage you, the potential comes to a screeching halt because you don't want to upset anyone.
It's condescending because the way you structure the posts, the way you carry yourself in the forums, and the name you've made for yourself makes it seem like no one but the people who refer to you as "Nuke" seem worth your time. I wonder why you don't just PM your ideas to those select members since apparently there are only a few people who's views you're after anyway. If cball11 or Peach_hat made a thread in a manner similar to this, they'd get ridiculed, or at the very least accused of trying to be like you a bit too much. I find your thoughts are accepted by everyone by virtue of an italicized user name, and that bothers me.
You're a fine poster and clearly a decent fellow, but the incongruities I observe in your forum behaviour are what bother me:
- Seeking intelligent discussion within the "I post/you post/I resolve" format
- Sacrificing journalistic integrity (I use that phrase apprehensively mind you) because your Watchmen review was not well-received
- Always feeling the need to justify yourself (Exactly what weight is given to your ideas because you reaffirmed your age and major?)
The Escapist is allegedly an above average forum and the desire to keep it that way is admirable, but do we really need to chastise those who make a few spelling errors and patronize the people who want a simple discussion or laugh? The constant need for the senior users to be introspective and psychoanalytical of themselves is foolish.
Ah hell, where to start? As far as the reconciliation goes... I'm a naturally sociable person. I've had experiences in the past that have ended with me being blocked, or shunned from a community, or judged, or any number of other allegedly reasonable ways to ostracize me from a community. Call it what you'd like, but I personally
hate having to give up friends and contacts because of a personal distaste, mistaken point, or even just a circumstantial event that may very well have been unavoidable. So call me naive if it makes you happy, but I'd like to think I
should offer the olive branch to people I can keep friendship with. I'd like to work out why you have a problem with the way I do things, not some freakin' sense of self-indulgence. If it won't work out, fine, but I'm making an effort in doing what I believe in. Maybe it's a sacrifice of moral integrity, or personal integrity, or whatever you'd like to call it... I don't like being put aside or belittled, and I like it even less when it was avoidable. I'm still trying to make it work, darn it, whether or not you agree with my olive branch be damned. I made an effort.
The "Nuke" persona is certainly one that fell on me by accident. Asking anyone who speaks to me on a regular basis knows that I'm self-depreciating, insecure, and generally "too nice for your own good." I have about as much self-absorbed pompousness as I do the ability to change the world to my whim. What I do have is a style that's been around for years. I actually have a fully formatted guide to basic Ragnarok Online interaction written for a server a year before I joined this site. If you look at the guide itself, the formatting looks terribly familiar. I'd written this way long before I even had be known as
NewClassic, much less "Nuke." As far as the everyone agreeing, I think my Watchmen review is proof enough that my writing isn't always there to receive universal love.
As far as the discussion, I'm glad to discuss. I do want to avoid disputes, not discussion. I'm noticing a trend of you having problems with what appears to be myself, not my opinions. Disagreements are those I can work out, personal problems I like to clear out. Call it my insecurity, or naivety, or anything else you'd like, but it's a part of my personality I'm completely content with.
As far as journalistic integrity, here's the small of it. Out of a total of 800 (approximately) words in that review, about 42 of them were in regard to nudity or pornography. Statistically speaking, 5.25% of my review had negatively mentioned nudity or pornography. Of the replies I got (37 total before the rewrite), 11 of them pertained entirely to the discussion of nudity and sexuality in the
Watchmen. Total percentage there is 27.3% (27.297297[sup]repeating[/sup]) in reference to something I only hinted on. From there, factor in a statement from
Fire Daemon suggesting I'm unclear. I've cleaned up reviews on suggestion before [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.82760], and re-writing my opinions' backing for
Watchmen is absolutely no different. The only thing I "removed" from the review is the multiple mentions of nudity (which was condensed into a final footnoted warning), which was the result of a joke I wrote at approximately 3:50 AM the night I watched the movie. I still make fun of it for the grievous sex-scene, and I'll still protest the nudity, but I'm not going to set up an easy punch-line for someone who wants to pretend a review is only about it's opening line.
As far as self-affirmation, I'm explaining. When people say, "You're asking for professional opinions from kids," I do indeed like to remind people that I'm not some great, golden, glowing MonitorHead in the sky.
I'm a kid too.
As far as self-analysis, everyone does their own thing. The fact that you appear in each of my threads with an opinion decidedly contrary to my own is no fault of yours, but berating my character in honor of your differing opinion is something else entirely. I get that you don't seem to want to be friends, or at the very least want to be confrontational. I don't like it, and I'm glad to dispute it. Pretension or no, you should approach me with problems instead of kicking dirt on my threads until I get offended.
Good day,
Maet.