BonsaiK said:
I love it how people rag on the far less artificial Auto-tune all the time, and blame it for killing music, but have no problem with Japanese vocaloids which are 100% computer-constructed.
I'm a little late to the game with this thread but I can argue your point easily. The reason people rag on auto-tune is that it's a system designed to fix a person's vocals, automatically fixing the pitch if needed to the point that even a talentless hack can sound like a pop goddess if needed. What's even worst is that now people like that robotic, purposely messed with sound that autotune creates that even if you suck at singing and people know it, it doesn't matter because they want to hear something that sounds like a robot anyways! You can see the horror this is creating for the music industry in this snippit from a documentary on it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=irk3_p15RJY&feature=related
Which brings me to the vocaloid system, that I don't see as something replacing musicians, so much as being a musical instrument in the process. Many people think that the lead singer is suppose to be the "face" of a band or that for the most part it revolves around them but that's not true, they SHOULD be just as important as the rest of its parts but society has made it that way on purpose. The only thing that really confuses the heck out of me is that they're putting
personalities behind these voices when in reality, it should be Saki Fujita, the one who did the voice sampling up there instead.