NO! The music is what I loved most about Silent Hill. The music is what kept me coming back and now instead of hearing the eerie briliance of Akira Yamaoka I'll have to suffer through what will most likely be a less than stellar story AND Korn?!
Yeah, Opeth are melancholy most of the time, not particularly creepy. If the soundtrack says, "Oh no! Some mopey flesh-sack monsters are going to come and sit around on my couch and watch reruns of CSI!" I'm not going to be scared.Shio said:Opeth? I can't see them doing anything creepy.Latinidiot said:That's.....strange.
If they wanted horror, why didnt they hire Opeth, or Unexpect? they're far more qualified than frikking Korn.
To be fair, I didn't take from this article that Korn was making ALL of the music, but just the theme song. So, they'll be making the song that we see in the trailers, ending credits and probably the opening as well. So I'm thinking like Simple and Clean from Kingdom Hearts. (And I'd be lying if I said I didn't like that song, despite my preferences in music) I just don't think every game needs a platinum selling band/artist to make their theme song. That's why game studios have music departments and composers. I don't think Silent Hill needs a catchy theme song, nor do I think Korn should be the ones making it.Shio said:I'm with you on that one; let professional composers create the music. It's pretty well impossible for a band (whose prime motive is entertainment) to create sound subtle enough to remain in the background consciousnesses and effective enough to create an atmosphere. I'm very into my music and love me some post-metal, so I'm not saying bands can't create atmosphere, mind.Saltyk said:Well, I was only half serious, to be honest. It's very rare that I would like a band to make a song for a game. I think we'd be better off letting composers make original music for games. That way there's no real conflicting style and the music can more properly fit the game and story. Let bands make their music and let game composers make theirs.Shio said:Rob (and White) are way, way too chauvinistic and melodramatic for Silent Hill. For some mindless slasher flick or game like Resident Evil sure. Not for something that relies on subtle, paranoid induced claustrophobia and panic, though.Saltyk said:Korn? That seems... odd. Don't get me wrong, I love Korn's old music, but the newer stuff has been pretty hit and miss (largely miss). They're claiming that they are trying to recapture that old feeling with their current album -that may or may not be out yet; I don't know- but I'm withholding judgment on that.
Wait, why is everyone saying that it should have been Trent Reznor? Where's the love for Rob Zombie? Doesn't a horror game kind of scream out for the Zombie? Forever Zombie, baby!
It's kinda sad that you're comparing Resident Evil to a mindless slasher flick, but that probably speaks more about what Capcom has done with the franchise that anything else. And to be fair, you statements about Rob (White) Zombie can be aplied to Korn, too. At least, in my opinion.
Well, I was more speaking to the films which I found to be super shallow and derivative of Western style horror. The early video games had something closer to the horror I enjoy, but even those had plenty of over the top monsters and relied almost entirely on jump scares. Resident Evil 4 was the only game in the franchise to actually scare me (as opposed to startle).
Yeah. It might turn out to be a great choice, but you don't really think of Korn when you think "great Silent Hill theme".Sinclose said:...What? :/
Well nothing to do but wait and see how this turns out, I suppose... although it is a pretty weird decision, especially for a Silent Hill game...