Wolyo said:
jamail77 said:
Not just the fluidity, she barely moves and never use her arms except when she sat down at the end but Korra was trying to sneak on her. Airbending is not even a problem for her now. And she can see everything, I'm pretty sure that's true, she's never been one to lie. Boast for sure but lie not really.
Best character of the two series, with Bolin
EXACTLY! Glad to know I wasn't the only one who thought that might be a sign of a vastly improved Toph, at least in terms of fighting and only compared to her
ATLA self rather than her interim self.
I would argue though that airbending was not a problem for her then either; after all, Toph can see attacks coming via vibrations regardless of whether the moves are rooted to the earth, so long as the person is rooted to the earth. I always thought it was the airbender strategy that Toph had a problem fighting against. Remember that when Toph first fought Aang he rarely spent much time making long, complicated ground movements. He spent most of the fight, if you could even call it that considering how averse to it Aang was, jumping around and landing so softly Toph barely felt vibrations. So, when he shot an air blast out at her and she saw the vibrations of the movement it was too late by then because 1) Airbending is fast, 2) It involves no physicality you can feel, and 3) he had just landed softly before he bothered striking and she lost track of where he was. Of course, I get the feeling you already know this and meant that more or less and I'm just focusing too much on the semantics/taking you too literally.
Personally, I'm partial to Tenzin, Varrick, and Wan as favorites for this series, but to each their own.
Wolyo said:
Rastrelly said:
I'm getting more and more bored and filled with sadness, and I cannot get all the amounts of praise Korra gets. Seriously. What do you guys see in this series? ATLA was epicly great, but Korra, IMHO, fails at every single aspect...
Why do you keep watching then?
To be fair, people watch stuff they dislike in the hopes it gets better. They often stick around because there are promising signs although in Rastrelly's case I doubt this considering Rastrelly said, "fails at every single aspect". It might be
ATLA nostalgia that keeps him coming, in the hopes he'll be watching an episode that has an
ATLA character in it. Frankly, "Why do you keep watching?" is an argument I'm kind of tired of seeing. Just because someone dislikes something doesn't mean they won't stick around for understandable reasons. I've certainly stuck around with stuff I don't like.
I would agree that voicing dislike in a forum thread related to a review that praises this episode is a little silly. He's just going to get a lot of backlash rather than insight. I doubt there will be a lot of people who don't like the show commenting here. It would be more appropriate to start his own thread, but there are already quite a few topics on how this show must be terrible and why does everybody like it so much. So, he'd kind of be beating a dead horse.
KazeAizen said:
jamail77 said:
While we're on the topic of Toph, did anyone get the feeling Toph was even more skilled/even stronger than she was in ATLA?
Not to sound like a jerk but it would be incredibly strange if she wasn't. I mean she was freaking good as a kid but she's what 10 there? Its been at least 74 years since then. If you aren't better at something at 74 then at 10 something went terribly wrong.
Don't worry, you don't sound like a jerk. I agree it would be strange if she wasn't a better fighter than she was as a still growing kid. To understand where I'm coming from, it's probably best for me to just quote the Facebook comment I made on the actual review:
Yeah, 12 is pretty young: Most people would get stronger than their 12 year old self. And, I know the Avatar universe has a lot of people who are strong despite their age, but, honestly, yes I am surprised. I had a hard time thinking Toph could get much more awesome than she was in ATLA. She was freakin' Earth runnin' MANY MILES back to Ba Sing Se after escaping capture and this was right after discovering metalbending, something I imagine had to have been somewhat tiring to do for the 1st time. I'm glad though. Toph was a fan favorite for a reason.
To reiterate, Toph was REALLY strong in
ATLA and I didn't see how she could improve much farther. It felt like she had reached a peak of earthbending, hence greatest earthbender in the world though really she might as well have called herself "The Greatest Earthbender Ever".