That's true - I think Ashley and Kaidan also suffered a bit from the fact that they had to be designed as exposition devices in this game so that we could learn all the back-story and in-game history that we needed to learn. True, all of our squadmates in ME1 are lumbered with the same problem to a degree (Tali maybe worst of all, since I think she's literally the ONLY quarian we meet in this game) but they all get the chance to keep developing their personalities across the trilogy, while Ashley and Kaidan, like you say, are designed to die interchangeably.
I forgot to count Cortez as a squadmate - he doesn't do a lot for me, TBH. I liked Traynor a lot more, but she got a lot more opportunities to be funny. I liked James a lot more after the Citadel DLC but still found him a bit bland overall. Maybe I just couldn't reconcile Freddy Prinze Jr's voice in that body
It occurs to me I completely left Zaeed and Kasumi out too. That maybe says everything that needs to be said about them, I guess in a similar way to Ash and Kaidan they're flawed in that they're DLC and therefore have to be written so it doesn't matter if they're there or not. I found both to be pretty one-note but still with some fun moments (particularly Kasumi and again, particularly in the Citadel DLC).
Nobody's mentioning any Ash favourite moments though - did I really pick the only one she's got?
I forgot to count Cortez as a squadmate - he doesn't do a lot for me, TBH. I liked Traynor a lot more, but she got a lot more opportunities to be funny. I liked James a lot more after the Citadel DLC but still found him a bit bland overall. Maybe I just couldn't reconcile Freddy Prinze Jr's voice in that body
It occurs to me I completely left Zaeed and Kasumi out too. That maybe says everything that needs to be said about them, I guess in a similar way to Ash and Kaidan they're flawed in that they're DLC and therefore have to be written so it doesn't matter if they're there or not. I found both to be pretty one-note but still with some fun moments (particularly Kasumi and again, particularly in the Citadel DLC).
Nobody's mentioning any Ash favourite moments though - did I really pick the only one she's got?