I guess it's kind of fruitless to start out my post by trying to make myself out as being somehow impartial, but I should probably start with a bit of context anyway. I grew up in a household that had primarily macintosh computers. My first job was working for a small town ISP (a job that also entailed a fair amount of computer maintenance), which both gave me considerable exposure to the Windows and Linux operating systems. My first computer was also a windows machine. The computer I primarily use for casual daily use at the moment is a Mac. I can't say that I'm an expert , but I'm not entirely ignorant of the subject.
In terms of stuff that an average user would do, there are very few real differences in user experience. Aside from incredibly specialize software, Macs generally have either a port or a comparable alternative. The browser you are currently using is probably available for Mac. Most of the productivity software you use is available for Mac. Hell, games aren't even as hard to come by as they used to be. The biggest difference, however, is that Apple has really tight control over it's products. This would seem like a universal negative to a PC hardware enthusiast, but it does have a huge advantage in some areas. While the whole "Macs never have problems" thing is very much a myth, I will say that I have seen far fewer driver issues and other weirdness. Furthermore, while the general (but not complete) lack of malware and security threats on Mac Os does have a lot to do with its tiny market share, it also has a lot to do with it's Unix heritage, which I'm told is incredibly resilient when it comes to security. Lastly, the operating system is quite "slick." I could probably find a more in depth design analysis somewhere, but between the unified aesthetics to the fact that the system tends to have fewer problems with odd system prioritization, it's about as close to hassle free as I can find in a modern operating system. Emphasis on the "close" (more on that later).
Most of you probably know the major downsides of windows, so I'm not going to go into them. Needless to say windows has problems. However, the nice thing about windows is that I can fix most problems. On a mac, problems are either simple solutions, or they need to be worked around. God forbid you have hardware problems with a Mac, especially the newer ones that are pretty damn difficult to service without simply giving in and paying a ton of money for Apple to do the repairs.
The majority of the rhetoric you hear about Macs was probably somewhat more grounded about ten to fifteen years ago when Apple gave a shit about their user base. They used to have awesome customer support and were incredibly easy to service. Hell, many problems that seemed almost certainly hardware related could be fixed by restarting. Further more, the hardware used to be less linearly comparable to other personal computers, which made a lot of the hardware arguments make a bit more sense. Now, it's just rhetorical bullshit.
In terms of cost, it is 100% objectively provable that you can get a much more powerful machine than any high end Mac for a fraction of the cost, especially if you build one. If you can service it, have more patience than the average user, and don't mind solving an odd puzzle here or there, Macs probably won't interest you. Still, I can't deny that there is certainly value in the craftsmanship and solid experience that comes with a Mac. Macs also have a tendency to have less of a performance loss over time that plagues many windows machines due to constant performance robbing software updates (or at least they did in the past, I wouldn't put Apple above planned obsolescence these days.) Of course, cost is less of an issue when buying refurbished (which usually translates to "bought but never used") Macs, which brings their cost down considerably.
Sadly, Apple and Microsoft are moving in a direction that I really hate. Apple isn't just about being streamlined anymore, it's increasingly more about control. Microsoft seems to be running on similar logic with their windows 8 business (though I doubt that they will being doing away will diversified hardware any time soon). Next time I get a computer, I'm probably just going to stop being lazy and just move completely over to Linux. It has it's downsides, but it getting increasingly less "scary" than Mac OS and Windows.
Closing thoughts:
Stop using the two button mouse argument, it makes you look like a tool.
Porn.
This [http://www.thebestpageintheuniverse.net/c.cgi?u=macs_cant] and this. [http://stuffwhitepeoplelike.com/2008/01/30/39-apple-products/]
Post edit-
xTc212 said:
Seems to be that every Mac user loves the operating system I will have to see if I can install it on my pc as a dual boot to see what it is like. Now to find a free trial
Keep in mind that while the Hackintosh community exists, Mac OS is not officially supported on anything that wasn't created by apple. Thus, you're probably not going to have nearly as good of a user experience as someone using it on a comparable apple product.