Marvel Considers Johnny Depp for Doctor Strange Role

faefrost

New member
Jun 2, 2010
1,280
0
0
I was kind of hoping that Disney would go for more of a non white ethnic direction with Dr. Strange. His background always made me think that he should be Indian. (Famous American Surgeon who has forgotten his roots. So much of the story revolves around India and Nepal etc on his journey of self discovery). Wouldn't someone like the guy who played the villain in this new Dhoom 3 work really well as Strange?
 

Foolery

No.
Jun 5, 2013
1,714
0
0
Feels like he's out of his Deppth to me. I'd rather have that dude who plays Littlefinger on Games of Thrones as Strange.
 

JarinArenos

New member
Jan 31, 2012
556
0
0
No no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no *gasp* no no no no no no no no no no no no


... I'm not sure how to evade low-content on this post. My mind is seriously just locking up in horror. Johnny Depp hasn't played anything but Captain Jack in over a decade, and I do NOT want to see Captain Jack Sparrow as Dr. Strange. Seeing Captain Jack Sparrow as the Mad Hatter was quite painful enough, thank you. And not NEARLY as fun as our other resident stuck-as-his-character, with "Tony Stark plays Sherlock Holmes".
 

LazyAza

New member
May 28, 2008
716
0
0
I think he could do a fine job as Strange. Just so long as they don't put a funny hat on him.
 

Therumancer

Citation Needed
Nov 28, 2007
9,909
0
0
Mr. Depp could do Doctor Strange, it would require a departure from some of his more recent, eccentric roles however. I look at his performance in "The Ninth Gate" as an arrogant, professional book thief who gets caught up in a search for satanic tomes able to unlock a gate to hell. That isn't exactly the way I'd expect him to play the role, but shows that he has the tools as an actor to not always play so outlandishly oddball.

To be honest also I would make a correction about something. The stuff about Asgard is NOT 100% science fiction, magic is heavily involved there along with advanced science. Loki, The Enchantress, Odin, Karnilla, all of them tap into actual Marvel magical forces. Karnilla is Asgard's "Sorcerer Supreme" each dimension has one, Doctor Strange is ours, she's theirs. So even if one uses the definition that the Asgardians *were* aliens they happen to be magic using aliens, or ones that wound up gaining the ability to use magic. Loki is for example not secretly walking around with a bunch of holo projectors in his gloves, and The Enchantress actually magically enslaves those she kisses, as opposed to relying on some kind of pheromone technology.

That said with Doctor Strange, the big problem with putting Johnny Depp into the role is he's another HUGE name actor who commands massive amounts of money for his time, and is going to compete for billing and screen time with other big name actors. How well he'd play the role isn't the biggest question here IMO, so much as whether having him do Doctor Strange means we'll actually get to see much use of Doctor Strange (who is one of my all time favorite characters).

I would also say that they could have some potential to do a "Defenders" movie like they did "Avengers" with "Doctor Strange" as the launch title, but they already decided to pull that name for "Netflix" ironically filling the team out with "Heroes For Hire" characters (all guys who seem to team with, and be built around Luke Cage, the only one notably missing seems to be Misty Knight as I believe Moviebob mentioned). "The Defenders" actually having started if I remember as being a team created by Doctor Strange to defend the earth against otherworldly threats other heroes weren't dealing with. One of the old school classic storylines was a misunderstanding (well actually several) leading to the "Avengers Defenders War" pitting the two teams against each other... with the predictable outcome of things eventually being sorted out before too much damage was done in the end. Something they could have in theory built a crossover of movie crossovers around. :)

At any rate I have still been hoping they take the "Defenders" name from Netflix and have them rebrand their crossover "Heroes For Hire" given that it makes the most sense since that's the family of characters they are using.
 

Callate

New member
Dec 5, 2008
5,118
0
0
1. "Thor" is science fiction in the way that "Star Wars" is science fiction.

"He's a god. He flies through the air with the magic of his hammer."
"No, he's an alien. He flies through the air with the technology of his hammer."
"But-"
"Science!"
"...B-but... Frost giants? Dark elves?"
" Science!"

2. Much as I hate to admit it, and as increasingly unlikely as it seems to be that we'll ever get a decent movie out of it... DC has far more interesting magic-users than Marvel.

Still, I'd have to view Johnny Depp and the kind of attention to detail Marvel has been lavishing on its movies of late would probably be a step in the right direction.
 

Mike Richards

New member
Nov 28, 2009
389
0
0
I get the feeling most of the people here concerned about his ability to play someone other than Captain Jack haven't seen the trailer for Transcendence yet. At this stage it's too soon to tell how good it'll be but it certainly has potential, and at the very least Depp seems much less 'wacky hats' then we've seen him in a long while.

I'm not as familiar with Strange as I am with other parts of the roster but from what little I know he certainly seems like a good call. There are definitely some other names I'd have on the short list too though, like the aforementioned Liam Neeson or even Hugh Laurie. I could see any of them
 

VoidWanderer

New member
Sep 17, 2011
1,551
0
0
Callate said:
1. "Thor" is science fiction in the way that "Star Wars" is science fiction.

"He's a god. He flies through the air with the magic of his hammer."
"No, he's an alien. He flies through the air with the technology of his hammer."
"But-"
"Science!"
"...B-but... Frost giants? Dark elves?"
" Science!"

2. Much as I hate to admit it, and as increasingly unlikely as it seems to be that we'll ever get a decent movie out of it... DC has far more interesting magic-users than Marvel.

Still, I'd have to view Johnny Depp and the kind of attention to detail Marvel has been lavishing on its movies of late would probably be a step in the right direction.
True. But the more 'memorable' magic-users are Zatanna, Circe... Captain Marvel (debatably), Doctor Fate... I can't think of any more.

I think Doctor Strange could be interesting, and Mr Depp can pull it off, as long as the director understands that Doc Strange is fairly straight-laced.
 

Callate

New member
Dec 5, 2008
5,118
0
0
VoidWanderer said:
True. But the more 'memorable' magic-users are Zatanna, Circe... Captain Marvel (debatably), Doctor Fate... I can't think of any more.
I was actually thinking more along the lines of Hellblazer, The Books of Magic and Sandman... But the less said about Constantine, the better.
 
Sep 14, 2009
9,073
0
0
Dead Century said:
Feels like he's out of his Deppth to me. I'd rather have that dude who plays Littlefinger on Games of Thrones as Strange.
oh god...you put that picture in my head, NOW I CAN'T TELL THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO CHARACTERS.

I also suggest this.
 

BoredRolePlayer

New member
Nov 9, 2010
727
0
0
I say we bring Vincent Price back to life and have him play the role, it's a match made in heaven I will never see :(.
 

Aramis Night

New member
Mar 31, 2013
535
0
0
I'm conflicted about this as well. I'm a big fan of Dr. Strange so this makes it harder for me. I admit, the idea of Liam Neeson or Aiden Gillen(Littlefinger) playing the role would be very intriguing. Of course what i really want to see is Peter Dinklage in the role of Galactus.
 

Aramis Night

New member
Mar 31, 2013
535
0
0
BoredRolePlayer said:
I say we bring Vincent Price back to life and have him play the role, it's a match made in heaven I will never see :(.
You just made me want to cry. But instead it looks like we are getting the guy who played opposite him in his final movie. Still not close enough though imo.
 

MorganL4

Person
May 1, 2008
1,364
0
0
Am I the only one who feels like some Disney exec looked and saw the name "Dr. Strange" and immediately thought, okay Dr. Strange, who is the "strange" actor, Johnny Depp!!! PLUS he got us SO MUCH money from Pirates of the Caribbean, where can we go wrong?

Right there. THAT is where you went wrong, the character himself is not all that strange.
 

MorganL4

Person
May 1, 2008
1,364
0
0
Aramis Night said:
I'm conflicted about this as well. I'm a big fan of Dr. Strange so this makes it harder for me. I admit, the idea of Liam Neeson or Aiden Gillen(Littlefinger) playing the role would be very intriguing. Of course what i really want to see is Peter Dinklage in the role of Galactus.

They can't use Galactus. he was in that Fantastic 4 movie, which means that he is now a property of Fox.
 

ckam

Make America Great For Who?
Oct 8, 2008
1,618
0
0
Well, OK? I guess he already looks the part. I wouldn't want him to do anything crazy though.
 

faefrost

New member
Jun 2, 2010
1,280
0
0
Aramis Night said:
I'm conflicted about this as well. I'm a big fan of Dr. Strange so this makes it harder for me. I admit, the idea of Liam Neeson or Aiden Gillen(Littlefinger) playing the role would be very intriguing. Of course what i really want to see is Peter Dinklage in the role of Galactus.
Nah. I wanted Dinklage Playing Puck from Alpha Flight
 

Adam Jensen_v1legacy

I never asked for this
Sep 8, 2011
6,651
0
0
Vivi22 said:
Adam Jensen said:
Uratoh said:
I don't like this idea...it's mostly because Strange always struck me as fairly 'straight'...he works with weird, twisted and unusual forces, but powers aside, he was always rather...non deppian, really. Probably oweing to his background as a surgeon.
Johnny Depp can still pull if off. He's an incredible actor. He's mostly known for his weird roles but he can play a normal guy as well. Check out some of his earlier work.
I actually agree with you that Depp is a great actor and can pull off the straight man roles. But I also have trouble seeing him as an iconic comic book character simply because he's so recognizable. He's one of those actors that just gets so much work that it's hard to see him on screen and not think "oh hey, it's Johnny Depp." I'm fine with that in roles where the character isn't already established, but it's hard to move on from with something like this.
And Samuel L. Jackson and Scarlett Johansson aren't recognizable? Samuel L. Jackson is EVERYWHERE like a GOD, and Scarlett is voted to be the sexiest woman alive (rightfully so!) twice!