Okay, guys, after reading the sheets over again, I see a fair few problems with some of them. I apologise in advance if I cause offence in any way. With that, here goes.
[hr]
[hr]
"On days when her clients were less intimate, she'd wear her armor under the dress, to be at the ready when the time was calling for it." Why does she do this? What purpose does this serve someone working for Sha'ira? It seems to me that there is a bit too much foreshadowing going on here, and not enough firewalling: keeping player knowledge separate from character knowledge.
[hr]
- Your character has an entourage. I said in the OP that participants are allowed one character total. The only exception is in my case, since as GM I frequently need to be in multiple places at once.
- According to the sheet, Karo "spots threats before anyone else". I don't like this; I feel it gives you too much power over almost any given situation. It may even allow you to ignore things I specifically say as GM.
- "one of the greatest assassins in the universe" - I see very little in your character's bio that backs this up. What has he done to earn this title? Karo's biography doesn't go into much detail on this matter.
- On that note, I advise that you invest in paragraphing. The bio just looks like a wall of text.
[hr]
- - To clarify the contradiction note: he is a glory seeker, but ignores what other people say about him?
- The Mary Sue-ish elements of your character, that I can determine, are thus:
- - He is unharmed physically or psychologically by jumping on a live grenade.
- - "gleaming white hair" just screams Sue to me.
- - He was born on a moon that doesn't exist.
- - Ryan only became a biotic after receiving the implants? That's not the way it works. Human biotics have to receive a significant amount of exposure to element zero, either in-utero or secondary exposure at a young age.
- In addition to that which is already pointed out about your character's backstory, I note that you have Recarius personally visit Ryan. He sends out messages via the extranet or personal courier to all people he considers useful when building his team.
- As with Supertegwyn, Ryan's biography is just a wall of text. Split it up into a few paragraphs.
[hr]
- A "forgettable face that isn't bad-looking" is both a contradiction and a hint at trenchcoating, which I dislike in characters.
- I have a few issues with your character's bio.
- - James received a contract to kill Recarius? That treads far too close to the plot that will unfold as the RP progresses.
- - - Also, Recarius wouldn't offer a chance at redemption to someone out to kill him. I doubt anyone else would either. A bullet to the head would prevent the problem from reoccurring.
- - Again, as with the two above, your bio is a wall. Paragraphing, people.
[hr]
To sum up, some things to applicants who haven't submitted a sheet:
- There are too many assassin characters: there are other walks of life that have yet to be considered.
- Also, Jira'Kilaye nar Chatani and the two asari characters submitted are the only females present. Some sexual diversity would be much appreciated.
[hr]
Your character is missing an important part of his bio. As a quarian, he would undergo the Pilgrimage, and experience life aboard a ship in the Migrant Fleet. Your character just 'starts' out of nowhere. Also, I need you to rewrite the Class and Talents entries to match the updated character sheet.Outcast107 said:-snip-
[hr]
I still have an issue with your biography.mcpop9 said:-snip-
"On days when her clients were less intimate, she'd wear her armor under the dress, to be at the ready when the time was calling for it." Why does she do this? What purpose does this serve someone working for Sha'ira? It seems to me that there is a bit too much foreshadowing going on here, and not enough firewalling: keeping player knowledge separate from character knowledge.
[hr]
- I feel that we have too many assassin characters.Supertegwyn said:-snip-
- Your character has an entourage. I said in the OP that participants are allowed one character total. The only exception is in my case, since as GM I frequently need to be in multiple places at once.
- According to the sheet, Karo "spots threats before anyone else". I don't like this; I feel it gives you too much power over almost any given situation. It may even allow you to ignore things I specifically say as GM.
- "one of the greatest assassins in the universe" - I see very little in your character's bio that backs this up. What has he done to earn this title? Karo's biography doesn't go into much detail on this matter.
- On that note, I advise that you invest in paragraphing. The bio just looks like a wall of text.
[hr]
- From first and second impressions, your character looks like a walking, talking contradiction/Mary Sue hybrid.Issurru said:-snip-
- - To clarify the contradiction note: he is a glory seeker, but ignores what other people say about him?
- The Mary Sue-ish elements of your character, that I can determine, are thus:
- - He is unharmed physically or psychologically by jumping on a live grenade.
- - "gleaming white hair" just screams Sue to me.
- - He was born on a moon that doesn't exist.
- - Ryan only became a biotic after receiving the implants? That's not the way it works. Human biotics have to receive a significant amount of exposure to element zero, either in-utero or secondary exposure at a young age.
- In addition to that which is already pointed out about your character's backstory, I note that you have Recarius personally visit Ryan. He sends out messages via the extranet or personal courier to all people he considers useful when building his team.
- As with Supertegwyn, Ryan's biography is just a wall of text. Split it up into a few paragraphs.
[hr]
- As with Supertegwyn, I feel that we have too many assassin characters. Maybe I'll accept two, but Kole Yossar (Captainguy42) is looking like the best one out of the three.staika said:-snip-
- A "forgettable face that isn't bad-looking" is both a contradiction and a hint at trenchcoating, which I dislike in characters.
- I have a few issues with your character's bio.
- - James received a contract to kill Recarius? That treads far too close to the plot that will unfold as the RP progresses.
- - - Also, Recarius wouldn't offer a chance at redemption to someone out to kill him. I doubt anyone else would either. A bullet to the head would prevent the problem from reoccurring.
- - Again, as with the two above, your bio is a wall. Paragraphing, people.
[hr]
To sum up, some things to applicants who haven't submitted a sheet:
- There are too many assassin characters: there are other walks of life that have yet to be considered.
- Also, Jira'Kilaye nar Chatani and the two asari characters submitted are the only females present. Some sexual diversity would be much appreciated.