Mind Racking Extra Credit Problem

[kmiik]

I would conclude that there is not enough information to determine anything. I say ask your teacher if there's anything else. Probably not but thats happened to me before that a teacher withheld information and we had to ask for it. Also, I think its a bad idea to assume you're playing clue. What class is this for?

 

[Smagmuck_]

Uh, uh, uh... Soilent greens are people! I'm sorry I'm so confused...

 

[G1eet]

Retort with another riddle.

What gets harder to see, the more of it there is?
<spoiler=Thank you, Benigni>Obscurity.

When you say my name, I am no longer there. What am I?
Silence.

 

[ajb924]

OBJECTION!
Your honor! This piece of paper clearly show's the contradiction in the witnesses statement!

I see nothing faulty

PENALTY

Fuck you, your honor.

Any who, there is nothing saying if you are not color blind you are not guilty, I'd go off of that.

 

[TheGreatCoolEnergy]

It wasn't Mr. Green, the evidence for his conviction is the inverse of the original statement, which is only true of a biconditional statement (if and only if), you can conclude that Mrs. Peacock is not guilty as well, because the evidence for her innocence is the contrapositive of the original statement, which is true as long as the original statement is.

Mr green may be guilty, but it isn't proven, Mrs Peacock isnt guilty

the dead man is Mr. Buddy, the dead guy in CLUE

The fact that i know that is a little disturbing

I second this, as my mind half exploded trying to sort throught that.
[sup]don't judge me[/sup]

 

[matsugawa]

I think I just had an aneurism.

Couldn't have put it better myself.

All I can say about the riddle is
1) your teacher is insane.
2) this is the most broken logic I've ever seen on anything claiming to be academic.
3) Mr. Body was the guy in the Clue games who was always the victim, so that could be the dead person's name.

 

[stone0042]

I hated this logic bullshit freshman year in math, too much wordplay. Well, the first statements logically incorrect, and the seconds true. That's all ive got

 

[stone0042]

Retort with another riddle.

What gets harder to see, the more of it there is?
<spoiler=Thank you, Benigni>Obscurity.

When you say my name, I am no longer there. What am I?
Silence.

Those were insultingly easy riddles. Challenge me!

 

[DazBurger]

Mr. Green is not the colourblind suspect!
Sergeant Gray is! Therefore HE is the murderer!

Dr. Black/Mr. Boddy is the victim.

How do I know this?

Because wikipedia says so...
[link]http://209.85.229.132/search?q=cache:nvz69JW9uqgJ:en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Cluedo_characters+cluedo+colour+blind&cd=5&hl=da&ct=clnk[/link]

 

[G1eet]

Retort with another riddle.

What gets harder to see, the more of it there is?
<spoiler=Thank you, Benigni>Obscurity.

When you say my name, I am no longer there. What am I?
Silence.

Those were insultingly easy riddles. Challenge me!

Blame Life is Beautiful. Those are the only two rational ones I can think of at the moment. Or do you want to be stuck in a logic loop?

Which came first, the chicken or the egg?

This statement is a lie.

All Cretans are liars.

 

[ObsessiveSketch]

don't leave us hangin dude!!! What'd your teacher say?

 

[stone0042]

Retort with another riddle.

What gets harder to see, the more of it there is?
<spoiler=Thank you, Benigni>Obscurity.

When you say my name, I am no longer there. What am I?
Silence.

Those were insultingly easy riddles. Challenge me!

Blame Life is Beautiful. Those are the only two rational ones I can think of at the moment. Or do you want to be stuck in a logic loop?

Which came first, the chicken or the egg?

This statement is a lie.

All Cretans are liars.

Eh, I was only kidding lol