Fair enough!MiracleOfSound said:You'd be amazed how many people complain that they are not literal enough and too 'metaphorical'. You really can't please everyone.HHammond said:The lyrics in Miracle of Sound are usually the weakest part of the songs for me and that held true here. They have a tendency to be a little too literal. Sometimes they sound a bit awkward and forced.
I should have clarified this. I meant mostly the rhythm and the melody but to a lesser extent.MiracleOfSound said:I'm all for constructive criticism but if you're trying to say you guessed the melody before you listened to the song then, well, I smell a big pile of BS and hyperbole.HHammond said:The melody in this case was really really predictable. As soon as I read the first line of the lyrics before the video started I then sang the next 4 before playing the song and I was about 90% right.
Okay, I'll give you that the songs are different but there is just something about them which, to me, feels a bit samey. I can't quite put my finger on it.MiracleOfSound said:Listen to Sweet LA, then Necromorph Soup, then Santiago's Lament, then this song, then Little Sister then Trip To Vegas and then try to tell me even one of them sounds remotely similar in genre or style to any one of the others.HHammond said:As for the backing, it was mostly alright. A bit cliched but alright. Again, experimentation with different rhythms and playing techniques would be great. This is something I really really liked about Rebecca Mayes. She experimented every week. Every new song was something different. Yeah, they didn't always work but it never stagnated.
I do like most of your music! Sorry if I offended you. Wasn't the intention. Just like you it was just my opinion. I was just stating that I felt this one hadn't done anything to me compared to some of your other music.MiracleOfSound said:You don't like the music - that's totally cool with me. No probs.
But saying it doesn't try to be experiment and differentiate is, in my humble opinion... BS.
P.S. Don't mistake this for aggression or pissyness - I totally respect your opinions. I just disagree quite strongly with some of them. I don't usually respond to these kind of posts, but tonight I feel like it.
One of the most important things to learn in this life is which criticism to listen to, but even more important is learning which to ignore completely.