I think that--so far--this is the best era for cartoons ever. And I don't mean just in the past few decades. I mean ever.
20s -- experimental and unfocused
30s -- yeah Popeye is fantastic, but only a minority of the episodes have actually interesting plots. Animation was still very much about spectacle over substance
40s and 50s -- again, Loony Tunes is eternal... but go watch some of them again. Same as before; only about 35% of the shows make up the 'classic roster' that we glorify today
60s and 70s -- while boasting an overwhelming roster of classics, I don't need to explain the flaws with Hannah Barbara, do I?
80s -- okay I'll be honest I'm not too familiar with this decade. I mean it was the golden age of Licensed toy shows, which brought about an unprecedented 'trans-media world' renaissance, but the writing and animation were still sub-par
90s -- Nicktoons were their own thing; crude and surreal. It was an interesting flavor, but still fairly limited. Powerpuff Girls and Dexters Lab were a more 'refined' brand of strange, and very appealing, but again, still kind of one note. Animaniacs I'd say is really great, but the animation is still really lacking (though not for the time). Batman... well okay Batman is unrepentant fantastic, but that's just one program.
00s -- Now here's the one I'm the most familiar with; the one that I was a kid during most of. *ahem*
Spongebob had great jokes and great characters and a unique, classic design aesthetic... but never ultimately did anything dramatic or meaningful with those wonderful assets. And from season four onwards, its creativity and timing were drained from it and it lives in an embalmed state to this day.
Fairly Odd Parents was really good, continued being really good, and remains really good to this day. Every time I pop in an episode once and a while, I am completely blown away at how it continues to keep the EXACT same energy and wit it had from day one. But still, it's always mostly been about the jokes and gags; the characters are likable and there's some good drama, but the show still is mostly there to make you just laugh. This isn't bad; I wouldn't want it any other way, it's just, well, I'll explain later.
Jimmy Neutron is classic; the cruddy animation is very appealing. The simple-looking characters were shockingly three-dimensional. The stories were creative and engaging. So yeah, pretty dang good. Just not great.
Codename: Kids Next Door. I was a complete, psychotic fan of this show. It was a completely over the top immature fantasy that never stopped hitting you in the head with its own self-confident ridiculousness. However, on reflection, it also completely sucks. It's a stupid, stupid show, and not that charming or likable either.
Danny Phantom. Okay I couldn't actually watch this show because my parents were like Oh, it's a ghost, and he takes over peoples' bodies; that's a bit too demonic. So to those who watched it, if it's a heart-warming epic existential drama, I'll be sure to re-qualify my statements about this Era.
Let's see... what else...
Oh, Kim Possible. Eh, pretty well done 'spy/superheroin' parody, but nothing more than that really.
Fosters Home: cool and creative and interesting. Very memorable, but not really 'mind blowing' in any way except a few of the character interactions.
Teen Titans. I hear some seasons aren't as good; but I haven't seen them. Because from the amount that I did see, I'd never, ever seen such a perfect balance of whoop-tastic action, wonderful character drama, and uproarious comedy. I've never seen anything but gold.
In the latter half of the decade, I felt cartoons really went downhill. It was the plague of awful, ugly-as-satan Flash animation like Johnny Test, and the main era of sub-par Spongebob ripoffs like Camp Lazlo. In '07, Phineas and Ferb came about. I acknowledge that it's really good, (and given that it's still going strong, people may qualify it as a 'modern' show, but I still classify it under the 00s umbrella; it's got 00s animation and a 00s writing sense.)
All in all, by the time the decade ended, I honestly felt like western, family-friendly cartoons were dead. Dead and burried, and--as my naive presumptuous self self thought--never coming back.
~~~~
So yeah, while the 90's and early-to-mid 00's really raised the bar in countless respects, they were still ultimately "goofy, funny little distractions", to put it harshly. With the exception of Batman and Teen Titans (huh. Pattern.), I personally don't think any cartoon was a monumental achievement of visual storytelling, and NO show period attained a superlative level of animation quality.
But hey, who expects all that from cartoons, right? That's not a bad thing. It's an animated TV show; it's okay that it's not a touching, epic adventure, right? It's okay that it will never look as good as Disney movies, right?
10's
Given my younger siblings, I still saw brief snippets of Nickelodeon and Cartoon network every day. In the early months of 2010, I started seeing ads for a new cartoon that was coming out. It seemed interesting; the animation was clean and sharp and CG'd, but in a good way; small, smooth lines and weird, unique character designs.
The dialogue samples in the ads sounded strange and new as well; characters talking differently than how cartoon characters usually talk.
But despite all that, my cynicism for animation at its peak at the time, all I could think to myself was,
"Okay, at best, this will be decent."
And then after it came out, I watched the first three, fresh new episodes. I was blown away. The pacing and tone were unlike anything I'd ever seen; the dialogue was like a new sub-language of english. Every tired and stupid cliche you'd expect... was no where to be seen. The blend of action and comedy broke even the standards set by Teen Titans. It was all the fun fantasy action of KND, with the amazing jokes of Spongebob and FoP, with the inciting and likable characters that were the best anyone could possibly imagine.
And to this very day, three years and dozens of episodes later, whenever I see an episode, by the end, I'm quivering in my seat; awe-struck and dazed by the sheer, incomprehensible, overwhelming, angelic over-the-flippering-top fantastic creative brilliance of Adventure Time.
It's the most popular thing ever to be invented, and I honestly still don't think it's overrated. It's rated exactly as much as it deserves.
So that's good, okay, but why do I still call this the best era for cartoons ever? I mean I have to have more reason than that!
~~~~
Another year or two goes by, and I keep seeing ads for this show called 'Regular Show'. Oh nice, clever. Ha. You picked a generic title. Funny funny. =\ Hate to break it to you, show; but Adventure Time gets to have such a base, simple title because it's good and classic enough to earn such an accolade. You, by all probability, are another boilerplate, run-of-the-mill moderately engaging time waster. You don't get to be that pretentious.
Oh, and you have a gumball machine as a character? And a random guy with a big pink head? Randomness by itself isn't funny. Whatever, let's give this 'Regular Show' a watch.
~Later...~
*PUKES CHUNKS ONTO THE CARPET* GAAHHAHAHAH! *WRITHES ON GROUND* BAAAHHHHAHAHAAAAH!!!! MAKE IT STOOOPP!!! I CAN'T STOP LAUGHING!!! *CHOKES* *CURLS INTO FETAL POSITION*
*rolls out of the room and down multiple flights of stairs* HAAA HA HA HA *OOF* AA HA HA *OOF* AHHH AHA HA *OOF* GRAWWW I am in incredible pain HA HA HA HA HA!!!!!!
*stands up and bangs fists and head against refrigerator* BLAHAHAHA HA HA! HE LIKE--HA--HE LIKE--HA HA HA HA, the four ducks turn into a giant man wearing jeans and BLAAHHAHAHAHAHAHA GAHHHHHH!!!!!!!
~Later...~
*goes back up to couch, holding guts in hand*
So yeah it was good.
~~~~
Great, Ultrahammer, that's all well and good; we have the most flamboyantly creative show ever put to air, and the funniest single entity to exist in human history. But is that really enough to justify your initial claims? What about a show that really has depth and a soul?
Well, for that, we go to the rebooted My Little Pony series.
When I saw the popularity, I thought it must have just ripped off Adventure Time or something... or thrown in a few random internet memes or something. But in April 2012 when I finally gave it a spin, about eight episodes in, I found my entire plane of existence completely consumed by it.
The world... is so illusive and inviting.
The animation... is the best ever to be made for television. Just, ever. Maybe some Anime is better; I don't know. But for western TV animation, this is the best ever. Ever.
The writing... while still pretty cliche and sometimes not it a good way, most of the time, it does its stories the RIGHT way and gives them the impact other shows fail to have.
And unquestionably most importantly; the characters are completely wonderful. The way they are realized and developed and interact is one hundred percent sublime, and the struggles and adventures they go through I've found deeply inspiring.
It has its flaws, but the things it does right are done SO right; the things that make it good are just so good, that I feel it is the best cartoon yet made. Or at least, the one with the biggest, warmest space in my heart; and the heart of millions of others.
~~~~
Oh, Gravity Falls. ...yeah it's good. Everything works. It's very entertaining. ...yep.
Sorry, but being anything less than golden masterpieces from Heaven in animation right now is just always going to be overshadowed. Sorry.
Oh and final word: Gumball is lame, pretentious and annoyingly uncreative.
Bye.