Although not given good reviews as a game(I thought it was great,mind you!), the First Blair Witch game Blair Witch: Rustin Parr,was the scariest game I ever played! Everything about it was dark and moody, and unlike games like resident Evil, it didn't throw 100's of zombies at you! It did things like having you walk down a small town's main street, at night, in a thunderstorm, with a small torch, trying to find the thing that ran out of your hotel room after searching for something!
Because the game didn't get good reviews (high 70's mostly) youcan pick it up cheap on ebay. I, for one, can heartily recommend it. I have been a PC gamer (not a console gamer at all!) for 20 plus years, with a collection of 500+ PC games, so I feel I know what I am talking about!
