Gxas said:
Everyone hated Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within.
I loved it.
I still don't know why people hated it...
I would have posted this as my answer to the thread, but I was ninja'd... Anyway, I have three main reasons that I think are the reasons people didn't like the film when it was released in the West. Bearing in mind that when it was released over here it was a pretty solid effort by Square Pictures to try and appeal to the mainstream audience and actually make a well-received mainstream film for the West.
1. The Uncanny Valley. Which is odd, because I have that film on DVD and I've seen it loads, and the characters have never once looked to me like they belong in the valley. They actually look like pretty realistic and well-designed CGI characters to me. Not creepy at all.
2. The 'Final Fantasy' tag. That alienated fans of the series who were pissed off to find it was set on Earth (albeit in the future) and didn't have any major links (at least, not the 'right' sort of links, like Moogles and Chocobos) to the games. It also alienated non-series-fans who felt it was more aimed at those who had played the games and enjoyed them, despite that not being true at all.
3. The fact that it's anime. Like it or not, unless you're aiming something at kids and it has the name 'Pokemon' or 'Digimon' somewhere in the title, it's not going to be successful in the Western film industry. A sad fact, but true, at least when FF: The Spirits Within was released. It's getting a bit better now with films like Ponyo and the like getting a better approach and marketing from the West, but there's still a long way to go, and anime is still generally seen as the domain of nerds and geeks. I can't even persuade my brother to watch any anime because he thinks it's really geeky, even though I've explained loads of times that watching anime is no different to him watching The Simpsons or Family Guy. They're both animated shows from a different country, after all (we're from the UK, for the record), the only difference is the style of art. He just doesn't care...
So yeah, those are the three main reasons I can think of. Sadly, when combined they led to a very lacklustre performance and set of reviews in the West, and the downfall of Square's film division (thus helping make their subsequent merger with Enix all the more vital for the company's survival). It's a shame, because it was a genuinely good film. It was simply a bit too ahead of it's time. Maybe when something similar is released in a few years, by that point anime will have found a much wider acceptance in the Western film industry, and maybe then we won't see such gems being heralded as a load of crap like this one was.