somonels said:
For instance, I'm running a Radeon HD 5770 graphics card and I've got a 750W PSU. You don't want to be running your power supply at full bore all the time, it's bad for it.
That's overkill my friend. Providing that PSU can deliver enough power on the 12V rails you can easily Crossfire with it.
Thing is, people pay way too much attention to a PSU's wattage, and wattage is far from everything. I've seen 1000W PSU's that could do fuck-all. Equally important questions are; is this PSU from a respectable brand (makes them way less likely to hurt your computer if they go down), can this PSU deliver enough power on the right lines and is this PSU efficient?
Especially the latter should be looked at, a PSU with 80%+ efficiency is ideal.
For your computer, a 550W PSU from a respectable brand like Corsair, XFX, Antec or Thermaltake would do the trick just fine. If you're planning on overclocking and/or getting two GPU's in the future, I advice looking for a 650W or 700W PSU.
Koroviev said:
Does the card manufacturer matter?
Fairly little. Some manufacturers clock their cards a little higher. The biggest difference is usually in the type of cooler they use. Worth looking at but not that much to worry about.
Also, I reckon that your CPU will be a pretty decent bottleneck when you get that new GPU. Just sayin'.