Okay, so I'll be honest that I didn't play WoW far enough to actually try all the features (I think I only got a gnome mage to level 11 before quitting), like raids and instance dungeons or whatever, but I think this just leads to the "dangling the carrot" argument made countless times by non MMO fans. I had a friend tell me that the game only really gets good when a character hits level 20, and it was kind of a turn-off point for me when I heard that because
A) What about all the previous leveling? What was all that for? If the game only gets to be "fun" when some hours are put into it, then what the am I doing with all the previous stuff before the "good bits"? It's even more ironic considering that I only tried the trial part of the game and that has an experience cap of level 20. Again, it feels like that juicy piece of candy left on a windowsill to taunt a poor child who doesn't have the money to purchase something sweet for Christmas.
B) The game is a time-sink, and while this is a matter of opinion, I understand that this is a standard trick all RPGs--single player and MMO--all do. I don't have anything against them, quite the opposite really as I do love them a lot (their original roots are linked to roguelike games). Yet I always made the analogy that I could play a "time wasting" game for one time fee and have the same fun and experience compared to another "time wasting" game that charges you to play to use your time for the "fun parts".
I do agree that this is by no means a "bad" game, it's quite addicting and a very successful game, but still the thought of that nearly 200 dollar price tag per year is extremely expensive to me compared to a similar game I can pick up for just 20-30 bucks.
Actually, I might have experienced something like the raid/instance dungeon scenario like WoW in a free to play MMO. "Requiem: Bloodymare" had a instance dungeon for me around level 14 that I needed to team up with 3 other players to finish, and it was quite a unique experience compared to the grinding in normal MMORPGs. Though I'm not sure if this is the "epic awesomness" some people would describe from WoW. *shrugs*