Nintendo Plummets in List of "Powerful" Japanese Companies

VG_Addict

New member
Jul 16, 2013
651
0
0
Mcoffey said:
Meanwhile Sega has expanded its popular brands to heights they've never reached before.
Um, what? I'm pretty sure the consensus is that Sega's IPs have decreased in quality since going third-party. Just look at Sonic.

Nintendo makes their games with the hardware in mind.
 

bluegate

Elite Member
Legacy
Dec 28, 2010
2,387
986
118
Dragonbums said:
It's still overall a pretty big fall from grace and whether or not it's since or because of third party doesn't change the fact that all of these occurred in the time that SEGA became third party.

Which is basically what I was getting at in my comment in response to the OP.
There still isn't a clear cause and effect relation between those two though, so I'm not sure how good of an example Sega would be for Nintendo. Even ignoring the fact that both companies are in different situations, industries and markets.

VG_Addict said:
Um, what? I'm pretty sure the consensus is that Sega's IPs have decreased in quality since going third-party. Just look at Sonic.
What happened with Sonic is that Team Sonic has had problems trying to figure out how to best transfer sonic from 2D to 3D. This can't be attributed to them not having their own proprietary hardware to develop the game on.
 

MrBaskerville

New member
Mar 15, 2011
871
0
0
VG_Addict said:
Mcoffey said:
Meanwhile Sega has expanded its popular brands to heights they've never reached before.
Um, what? I'm pretty sure the consensus is that Sega's IPs have decreased in quality since going third-party. Just look at Sonic.

Nintendo makes their games with the hardware in mind.
I don't know, Sonic started sucking long before they went third party. Just look at stuff like Sonic Spinball, Sonic 3D or any attempt to follow in Mario 64s footsteps. There's plenty of shitty spinoffs and similar that indicates that Team Sonic might have lost some important creative people along the way.
 

Dragonbums

Indulge in it's whiffy sensation
May 9, 2013
3,307
0
0
Mcoffey said:
The WiiU has no chance of turning it around. It's doing worse than the Dreamcast did in it's day.
Considering how the majority of the issues with the Wii U surrounds around poor advertising I'm pretty sure that is easily fixable.

Also, the Dreamcast had a whole lot of factors surrounding it and before and during launch. A lot of it being releasing consoles in 3 year intervals, losing stock to Sony, losing money in arcade, etc. etc.




Meanwhile Sega has expanded its popular brands to heights they've never reached before.
Yes, Sonic for the longest time got shit ratings, they got ripped off of millions of dollars on A:CM because Gearbox are assholes, went through a lot of restructuring, and suffering from financial troubles. They surely have reached new heights of mediocrity and struggles.


Nintendo can only prosper by going third party.
False. Seriously. That's all there is to it.



It was great to hear they're taking another look at mobile and tablet.
For you.

It's hopefully a sign that they can break out of outdated business patterns and be successful again.
So by that logic Sony and Microsoft should go third party because they are participating in outdated business practices. We all know they will be oh so much more successful.
 

VG_Addict

New member
Jul 16, 2013
651
0
0
I'm surprised other people haven't pointed this out, but Nintendo's current situation is similar to Sony's position last gen: Coming off a gen where their console dominated, only to undo all of it with a console that's difficult to develop for, and launching with no good games.
 

JCAll

New member
Oct 12, 2011
434
0
0
MrBaskerville said:
I don't know, Sonic started sucking long before they went third party. Just look at stuff like Sonic Spinball, Sonic 3D or any attempt to follow in Mario 64s footsteps. There's plenty of shitty spinoffs and similar that indicates that Team Sonic might have lost some important creative people along the way.
Sonic's stock started tanking when the Saturn didn't have a real Sonic game. I still say his Dreamcast games were decent, and he didn't go to hell until SEGA went third party. And there have still been a few good ones since then too.
 

Roxas1359

Burn, Burn it All!
Aug 8, 2009
33,758
1
0
VG_Addict said:
I'm surprised other people haven't pointed this out, but Nintendo's current situation is similar to Sony's position last gen: Coming off a gen where their console dominated, only to undo all of it with a console that's difficult to develop for, and launching with no good games.
Ironically enough I've been making that comparison for quite a while now actually. The Wii U is Nintendo's PS3, in that they made a lot of stupid decisions that bit them in the butt. If that's the case then next gen means it should be good for them if they actually fix some of the issues like how the PS4 fixed a lot of the issues it had.
Still won't stop the complaining, but that's a given because that will never stop no matter what.
 

Aiddon_v1legacy

New member
Nov 19, 2009
3,672
0
0
Dragonbums said:
Thing is Iwata clarified his comment about smart phones saying that Nintendo STILL isn't interested in putting their titles on them:

http://blogs.wsj.com/japanrealtime/2014/01/20/nintendos-woes-dont-mean-game-over-for-its-consoles/

We might seem some tie-in apps, but don't ever expect full titles like Pokemon, Mario, Zelda, Metroid, Fire Emblem, Smash Bros, etc on them. At this point Nintendo is pretty much immortal.

Oh, and it does seem that while most people will talk about how Nintendo's stock went down 18%...they then forget to mention the market CLOSED with it only having drop 6% when all was said and done.

http://www.gonintendo.com/?mode=viewstory&id=220750

I really wish people would stop half-assing their jobs
 

VG_Addict

New member
Jul 16, 2013
651
0
0
Honestly, I don't think ONE bad console gen is going to kill Nintendo, especially after coming off the Wii and DS, both of which were insanely profitable. Hell, it took Sega several consecutive failures to go third party.
 

Roxas1359

Burn, Burn it All!
Aug 8, 2009
33,758
1
0
Aiddon said:
Oh, and it does seem that while most people will talk about how Nintendo's stock went down 18%...they then forget to mention the market CLOSED with it only having drop 6% when all was said and done.

http://www.gonintendo.com/?mode=viewstory&id=220750

I really wish people would stop half-assing their jobs
While it's good that Nintendo managed to make back a lot of the stock, the fact that it still closed the day down 6.15% still isn't very good. Especially since after E3 Microsoft's stocks fell only 1.34% after the price of the device and the other "features" were announced. Nintendo is bound to make them back, but this really sort of negates some of the stock they gained after China removed the console ban, so at least they still have around 5% or so more from that. But sudden changes like that aren't good at all.

Also, the BBC reported the loss as it happened, which is generally what major news sites will do as it happens. Now if they don't update it then it's their fault, but at the time they reported it the stock loss was correct. If they don't update it then they are in the wrong, but seeing as in the link you posted how there are people claiming "The BBC has something against Nintendo" then I find that just plain sad because the BBC has a lot more to report on than one singular company that makes entertainment devices, and that was a big stock loss of the day at the time. If it were Sony that lost all that stock then they'd report that.
 

Winterfel

New member
Feb 9, 2011
132
0
0
Mcoffey said:
Maybe a change of captains could be beneficial. Iwata's done some good work in his time, but he's also the guy who steered Nintendo into this shitstorm. Ideally, someone who sees the value in going third-party.
It's frankly more realistic to see them going full hand-held. It's like people forget about how amazing the 3ds is in the midst of the Wii U shitstorm.

And just to put in another point, you think you want Nintendo 3rd party, inbefore you realise how great SEGA became after they went 3rd party. I would honestly rather see Nintendo going off the games market completely before they go 3rd party.
 

Atmos Duality

New member
Mar 3, 2010
8,473
0
0
Winterfel said:
It's frankly more realistic to see them going full hand-held. It's like people forget about how amazing the 3ds is in the midst of the Wii U shitstorm.
They wouldn't have to if they just released some fragging games on it already.
The 3DS? Yeah, lets not forget that it was a FAILURE for its first year.

Because, and forgive the repetition, it had no sodding games. But eventually it got games and it turned around.

The 3DS is selling mainly on 1st party titles. Check its quarterly best selling lists and at any given time you will find Mario and Pokemon occupying most of the top 10 spots.

If the appeal of Nintendo consoles are the Nintendo games, then they need to get the lead out.
They should have gotten the lead out already, given the WiiU had a solid year head start on its newer competition.
 

Lt. Rocky

New member
Jan 4, 2012
158
0
0
Oh man, I really wanna know where Capcom is on that list. It'd probably give me such a laugh.
 

Roxas1359

Burn, Burn it All!
Aug 8, 2009
33,758
1
0
Lt. Rocky said:
Oh man, I really wanna know where Capcom is on that list. It'd probably give me such a laugh.
Capcom is above Nintendo currently. It's because in Japan, Capcom has actually had some recent successes, mainly thanks to Monster Hunter 4 being on the 3DS.
 

balfore

New member
Nov 9, 2006
74
0
0
I don't understand people who claim Nintendo going third party would be the death of them. It's plain and simple the appeal and benefits of being third party. As much as I love Nintendo, I'd rather be able to play one of their new games on a console I currently own and not shell out $200+ for me to only play one or two of Nintendo's first party games.
 

Steve Waltz

New member
May 16, 2012
273
0
0
Mcoffey said:
Meanwhile Sega has expanded its popular brands to heights they've never reached before.
I'll agree with you when I see Vyse and Aika in a new game rather than just cameos in other games.

Neronium said:
Ironically enough I've been making that comparison for quite a while now actually. The Wii U is Nintendo's PS3, in that they made a lot of stupid decisions that bit them in the butt. If that's the case then next gen means it should be good for them if they actually fix some of the issues like how the PS4 fixed a lot of the issues it had.
Still won't stop the complaining, but that's a given because that will never stop no matter what.
They would still have to clear the stigma that comes with buying a Nintendo console in the USA. Any "adult" my age would have to keep it a secret if he bought the Wii U for himself if he doesn't want to get laughed at. The Wii had a reputation in the USA for being a console for children and "casual" gamers (I still don't understand why being a casual gamer is a bad thing but?). Nintendo's best shot was to give their next console a brand new name and wipe the slate clean, but no, they named their next console after the Wii and the stigma stuck around. Nintendo really needs to show "hardcore" gamers that buying their console isn't just something for children if they want to turn this thing around.

I mean, the 7th Gen consoles all had a negative rep. PS3 had no games, 360 was breaking all the time, and the Wii was for kids. All of those negative reps were fixed except for one, and that one has stuck around for the next console and it looks like it's pulling the pulling the company into the ground.