Nintendo's SNES Classics Coming to New 3DS

Covarr

PS Thanks
May 29, 2009
1,559
0
0
ShadowHand25 said:
What pisses me off is the original launch day 3DS is perfectly capable of playing downloaded GBA games just fine, and the GameBoy Advance was far better technically than the SNES.
So either Nintendo is full of it, and wants people buying the New 3DS for these arbitrarily exclusive features, or there is something a 90's home console is capable of that a 2000's handheld console that's superior in almost every way isn't.
Or the 3DS literally has complete GBA hardware built-in for DS backwards compatibility purposes (you'll note that it doesn't support many 3DS features in ambassador games such as sleep and home menu), but does not have SNES hardware and would have to resort to emulation, which is much more demanding than running a game natively.

P.S. Thanks
 

WNxSajuukCor

New member
Oct 31, 2007
122
0
0
Think of it in terms of drivers for Windows. A driver for Windows XP will not work for Windows 10. The technical coding language on how to access resources, determine AI, calculate damage, etc etc, have drastically changed over the years.

We're also talking about emulation, not remaking. I'm sure anyone could remake, and thus recode, the entire game for newer hardware, but then you leave the quirks out from the original limitations of the hardware. For example: the Mega Man games on NES had quirks where there were too many enemies on screen, how firing your main canon worked, etc. If Mega Man was recoded to remove these quirks then it would not be the same game. Do you then release the game as is, without the quirks gamers grew up to love and potentially alienating those gamers who grew up playing with them in, or do you now code in the limitations in for a more "authentic" experience? Coding in the limitations would probably take even longer than getting an emulation running.

In an emulation the framework behaves like it would running on the old hardware, thus keeping all the quirks, bugs, and issues thereof. It would be a more authentic experience just like in the old days.

Okay, so now you decide you want to emulate rather than remake. If we use the original analogy of Windows XP and Windows 10 Microsoft has used .NET Framework and DirectX over the years for games and apps. Games that used an older versions of these frameworks have had issues running on newer versions of the framework and even newer hardware. A 386 behaves differently than a i7 in how it accesses information. So now you're trying to emulate old hardware framework on new hardware, with different coding languages and access speed. It's easier when the new consoles was built with these older frameworks, and in some cases older hardware, built right into the new console itself. It can take advantage of running precisely how the old console worked.

So, to SNES and 3DS. There's some emulation built into the console with the Virtual Console project. The 3DS is a powerful piece of hardware, able to run 3D images without glasses and all that, but it's still limited on how things were built into it. It's not just about emulating the game 1:1, but also getting it to run on the 3DS framework without crashing. The 3DS runs it's "Operating System" in the background along with the game. Factors have to be taken into account of how SNES games would react when suspended into the 3DS OS. Let's say you suspend the game halfway through the game accessing a sprite. When you resume the game is the framework going to continue loading the sprite correctly, or will Bowser be missing an arm or a leg? Will Mother Brain just be a floating jar? Will sound play correctly or buzz and hiss when it comes to a corrupted piece of music or soundbyte?


tl;dr: It's about a 1:1 experience without new bugs from newer hardware. It's easier to remake than emulate, but that kills the experience from the old hardware.
 

WeepingAngels

New member
May 18, 2013
1,722
0
0
Gordon_4 said:
They finally do a re-release of Super Mario World, and it's one the new platform I don't own - Nintendo you cunning bastards.
Super Mario World has been re-released on the Wii, Wii U and now new 3DS. It's also been remade on the GBA which can be played on the GBA, DS and Wii U.

Are you really having a hard time playing this game?
 

WeepingAngels

New member
May 18, 2013
1,722
0
0
ShadowHand25 said:
What pisses me off is the original launch day 3DS is perfectly capable of playing downloaded GBA games just fine, and the GameBoy Advance was far better technically than the SNES.
So either Nintendo is full of it, and wants people buying the New 3DS for these arbitrarily exclusive features, or there is something a 90's home console is capable of that a 2000's handheld console that's superior in almost every way isn't.
The SNES wasn't pulling all it's own weight, some of the carts had special chips in them to help boost the capabilities of the SNES. I think people have tried to run SNES emulators on the 3DS and it just doesn't work very well.

My problem here is that they want us to buy these damn games again. I bought the digital version of Super Mario World on the Wii and then the $2 upgrade fee on the Wii U and now they want me to pay $8 to play it on the 3DS.
 

WeepingAngels

New member
May 18, 2013
1,722
0
0
OuendanCyrus said:
I want to be able to play GC games on the Wii U or something, I never owned a GC and want to play TTYD so badly.
So buy a Wii or a Gamecube and play TTYD? I just don't understand this attitude that a game must be remade/re-released for people who "want to play it so badly" to buy it and play it. It's not like a used Gamecube or Wii is overly expensive and TTYD, while sort of expensive is not rare.
 

Gordon_4_v1legacy

New member
Aug 22, 2010
2,577
0
0
WeepingAngels said:
Gordon_4 said:
They finally do a re-release of Super Mario World, and it's one the new platform I don't own - Nintendo you cunning bastards.
Super Mario World has been re-released on the Wii, Wii U and now new 3DS.
Haven't owned a Nintendo home console since the N64 nor do I own the New3DS - so those were no help.


WeepingAngels said:
It's also been remade on the GBA which can be played on the GBA, DS and Wii U.
Huh, don't own a Gameboy Advance or old DS either, so that's even less help.

WeepingAngels said:
Are you really having a hard time playing this game?
Hard time playing it? No, I'm a dab hand - no expert but I'm okay. Finding it on a compatible platform, that I'm having a hard time with.
 

Yopaz

Sarcastic overlord
Jun 3, 2009
6,092
0
0
ShadowHand25 said:
What pisses me off is the original launch day 3DS is perfectly capable of playing downloaded GBA games just fine, and the GameBoy Advance was far better technically than the SNES.
So either Nintendo is full of it, and wants people buying the New 3DS for these arbitrarily exclusive features, or there is something a 90's home console is capable of that a 2000's handheld console that's superior in almost every way isn't.
Perfectly capable as long as they pretty much shut down the OS completely. I wouldn't say that's perfect, but I am not a dictionary. The question now is, do you dare to admit that you're wrong?
 

OuendanCyrus

New member
Jun 16, 2010
250
0
0
WeepingAngels said:
OuendanCyrus said:
I want to be able to play GC games on the Wii U or something, I never owned a GC and want to play TTYD so badly.
So buy a Wii or a Gamecube and play TTYD? I just don't understand this attitude that a game must be remade/re-released for people who "want to play it so badly" to buy it and play it. It's not like a used Gamecube or Wii is overly expensive and TTYD, while sort of expensive is not rare.
... Because I don't to buy another entire console just to play the one game? I alredy have enough wires running across my floor and hardware hooked up to my TV as it is. I wanted to play Super Metroid but never owned an SNES either and guess what? I was able to play that because I owned a Wii at one point. I apologise if I somehow baffled your mind by having the audacity to want to play an old video game on a current console.
 

WeepingAngels

New member
May 18, 2013
1,722
0
0
OuendanCyrus said:
WeepingAngels said:
OuendanCyrus said:
I want to be able to play GC games on the Wii U or something, I never owned a GC and want to play TTYD so badly.
So buy a Wii or a Gamecube and play TTYD? I just don't understand this attitude that a game must be remade/re-released for people who "want to play it so badly" to buy it and play it. It's not like a used Gamecube or Wii is overly expensive and TTYD, while sort of expensive is not rare.
... Because I don't to buy another entire console just to play the one game? I alredy have enough wires running across my floor and hardware hooked up to my TV as it is. I wanted to play Super Metroid but never owned an SNES either and guess what? I was able to play that because I owned a Wii at one point. I apologise if I somehow baffled your mind by having the audacity to want to play an old video game on a current console.
With all due respect, it doesn't sound like you want to play it "so badly". When I want to play something "so badly", I find a way to make it happen. I remember years ago you could get a Gamecube from Gamestop for $30, that included one controller. When they are in stock, they are now only $20 (link below). I used to have alot of old consoles, you know what I did about the wire problem? I put the consoles that wouldn't fit neatly into a closet. It's too bad you didn't play TTYD when you had a Wii. It is a great game.

http://www.gamestop.com/gc/consoles/gamecube-system-gamestop-refurbished/36647
 

OuendanCyrus

New member
Jun 16, 2010
250
0
0
WeepingAngels said:
OuendanCyrus said:
WeepingAngels said:
OuendanCyrus said:
I want to be able to play GC games on the Wii U or something, I never owned a GC and want to play TTYD so badly.
So buy a Wii or a Gamecube and play TTYD? I just don't understand this attitude that a game must be remade/re-released for people who "want to play it so badly" to buy it and play it. It's not like a used Gamecube or Wii is overly expensive and TTYD, while sort of expensive is not rare.
... Because I don't to buy another entire console just to play the one game? I alredy have enough wires running across my floor and hardware hooked up to my TV as it is. I wanted to play Super Metroid but never owned an SNES either and guess what? I was able to play that because I owned a Wii at one point. I apologise if I somehow baffled your mind by having the audacity to want to play an old video game on a current console.
With all due respect, it doesn't sound like you want to play it "so badly". When I want to play something "so badly", I find a way to make it happen. I remember years ago you could get a Gamecube from Gamestop for $30, that included one controller. When they are in stock, they are now only $20 (link below). I used to have alot of old consoles, you know what I did about the wire problem? I put the consoles that wouldn't fit neatly into a closet. It's too bad you didn't play TTYD when you had a Wii. It is a great game.

http://www.gamestop.com/gc/consoles/gamecube-system-gamestop-refurbished/36647
Unfortunately I do not have Gamestop anywhere near where I live. Only GAME. The only second hand game stores near me are CEX and none of them have Gamecubes or Wiis or even a copy of TTYD. I'm a bit iffy on buying used consoles online but that's just a personal thing that I have.
 

Sheo_Dagana

New member
Aug 12, 2009
966
0
0
SNES, eh, that's cool and all but I'm wondering when in the hell they're going to finally put some GBA titles up on their shop for download. They gave away a bunch to Ambassadors, and while I was happy with most of them, there are definitely some I would totally just BUY if they put them up on the shop. If they're having trouble getting SNES games to work on the 3DS or whatever, why not just put up the stuff you know people will buy?
 

Kingjackl

New member
Nov 18, 2009
1,041
0
0
Very disappointed by this. I only heard there were SNES games on 3DS at first, didn't realise it was exclusive to the new one until I ran to the store to pick up Earthbound and got told no.

My brother has a new 3DS though; think I might steal it.