No Right Answer: Best Version of A Christmas Carol Ever

[Asita]

Yes, Chris went easy on Kyle by not arguing that the Muppet Christmas Carol is also the best *musical* version of A Christmas Carol.

I don't know about that. As much as I love Muppet Christmas Carol, Scrooge with Albert Finney did a pretty spectacular job of it too. Take this little number as a case in point:


It's a catchy number in its own right, but at the same time it shows just how much everyone reviled Scrooge, and just how oblivious he was to that fact. More than that though, it serves to show just how much he actually craved that kind of recognition, despite actually singing earlier in the film about how much he hated people in general.

 

[desverger]

The only version of A Christmas Carol I need is the one from Blackadder.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rz54prceJIo

 

[Monty McDougal]

When he says his name, it sounds like "My Cocaine."

 

[BrotherRool]

I think the book was my favourite version

 

[GonzoGamer]

+1 to Muppets because Beaker gives Scrooge the finger.
Never thought of Scrooge as an Anti-Muppite.

For me though it's always been between the old Scrooge with Albert Finny & Mr Magoo Christmas Carol.
How can you not love that?

I don't know about that. As much as I love Muppet Christmas Carol, Scrooge with Albert Finney did a pretty spectacular job of it too. Take this little number as a case in point:

It's a catchy number in its own right, but at the same time it shows just how much everyone reviled Scrooge, and just how oblivious he was to that fact. More than that though, it serves to show just how much he actually craved that kind of recognition, despite actually singing earlier in the film about how much he hated people in general.

Glad I'm not the only one who loves that version.
Also, it has Obi Wan in Hell.

 

[Evil Smurf]

I think the book was my favourite version

The book is the best version, I was a little disapointed Die Hard was not mentioned.

 

[Lunar Templar]

No the muppets do not necessarily make anything better

this.

besides, the version with Patric Stewart is better

 

[Firefilm]

What happened to your column, guys?

unfortunately with the Escapist being bought by the larger media company, some loiter trafficked products had to be cut. But don't worry, because No Right Answer is still wildly popular and went be going anywhere.

You can always ask us anything you like on the NRA Facebook fan page!

 

[putowtin]

Scrooged out of the two but I do have a soft spot in my heart for the Muppets

(Though I'm also a big fan of the Patrick Stuart and Albert Finney versions)

But who can beat Bill F@!king Murray?!?!

 

[DuelLadyS]

Albert Finney is the one we watch every year (I'm glad to see others do too!), but mom loves Christmas movies and she'll squeeze in as many as she can- I've pretty sure I've seen every version of a Christmas Carol mentioned so far. (Personally, I just make it a point to watch Will Vinton's Claymation Christmas- but that's a tangent.)

 

[RJ 17]

Is that what the drinking round is for? I maybe started watching this show a month or two ago and never understood that part.

My understanding is that the drinking round just gives them x amount of time to try and squeeze in a few more points. But if one manages to make the other laugh while he's drinking, then the guy that laughed while drinking is disqualified. It's happened a couple times in the past, but for the most part the winner is decided before they even do the Drinking Round.

OT: Despite the disqualification, I've gotta say my vote would go for Scrooged because of two simple words: Bobcat Goldthwait.

That and I think it's funnier in general.

 

[i64ever]

Michael Cain > Bill Murray

Case closed

 

[Nurb]

"The ***** hit me with a toaster..." This scrooge wins hands down

 

[gambler778]

I am completely disappointed by the lack of Patrick Stewart's version. His performance was absolutely incredible, such an enjoyable movie to watch.

 

[Aptspire]

As I sit here twirling a replica of the 11th Doctor's Sonic Screwdriver in my fingers, I say unto you...

"No mention of the Doctor's Christmas Carol? With the flying sharks and everything?!? SHAMEFUL!!!"

CAPTCHA: call me maybe

GAH!!! Now even the Captcha's into that song!!!

I was like "Dan! Say something! The Doctor ACTUALLY TIME TRAVELS TO MAKE IT HAPPEN!!!"
Also, Dumbledore is Scrooge, your argument is invalid...

 

[darkbshadow]

The Muppets Christmas Carol all the way. For one main reason. You can watch the Muppets Christmas Carol with the whole family. You can't do the same with Scrooged. I know my nephews would get scared by that movie.

 

[axlryder]

Scrooged was a freaking terrible movie. It had a few decent moments, but overall it was a cobbled together, awkward mess with uneven tone and unconvincing performances.

Muppets wins this, hands down.

 

[Redd the Sock]

Muppets for me, but I guess it comes down to a level of taste, and I prefer a more traditional telling. I scores bonus points for me by being one of the earliest versions I saw that got and properly conveyed that Scrooge wasn't one dimensionally greedy and evil, but more tragic and broken.

 

[octafish]

And Tiny Tim?
...and to Tiny Tim WHO DID NOT DIE! Scrooge.was like a second father.
Isn't that swell?

Muppets all the way.