Eruanno said:
Oh please let Yahtzee do these reviews...
He is at his best when he hates something, and he generally hates anime, so it would be amusing to see him review some. I would both laugh very hard and have homicidal impulses if he reviewed Haruhi.
But overall this is a good idea. Some anime reviews would be nice, and there is a pretty substantial overlap between gamers and anime fans (though it's more apparent on other sites; at least partly because of Yahtzee this forum does a lot of anti-Japanese pop culture/anime/JRPG backlashing).