Objectively good, subjectively bad

[DRes82]

Dragon Age. Still haven't finished it. Doubt I ever will.

Depends on which one you're talking about. DA:2 totally agree. DA:0, on the other hand, might be worth a revisit to you.


OT: I'm gonna agree with op. Bioshock. I just couldn't get into it. Amazing story and good art design.

 

[Awexsome]

Half Life series. I respect the stuff it's done for PC gaming in particular since I never was into it in the first place but subjectively I'd call Halo (one that I'm sure fits this description for a lot of people on this site) better than it in every way. Story, gameplay, polish, atmosphere, music, everything.