I always viewed Chell as the straight man (Woman) of the series, in contrast to the insanity of the aperture labs. You wouldn't think she actually cared about the cake or the companion cube and seeing that sort of portrayal of her character took me out of it. Also, this is isn't important (maybe it is) but at this particular point in the timeline. the seven hour war has come and gone. A more interesting concept would be an out of the oven and into the fire scenario where she escapes Aperture only to immediately encounter the combine. At the very least I would have expected more combine/dystopic imagery.
We are allowed to dislike something, just as much as you are allowed to like something. Just because we have a differing opinion on a video doesn't mean we need to "Chill out". I know you are trying to act like the "Cool internet guy that puts all the 'haters' in their place", but you are just coming off as conceited.MarsProbe said:Very good, I approve of this creation. Some nifty uses of portals there, from the backscratching to putting rubbish in the bin.
As an aside, I wonder why it is the Facebook comments for this short film are all (so far) positive while a lot of the ones that appear here on the forum are so generally a lot more whiney and full of nitpicking. Escapists, are you really all just that hard to please, or is it just that (perish the thought) the relative anonymity of the forums grants you the chance to be a bit of a grouch.
If the latter is true, then colour me disappointed. Chill out people, seriously. You are allowed to just enjoy something every now and then. It won't hurt.