Thank you for restoring my faith in people on the internet!coldfrog said:Perhaps the previous owner had been stabbed to death by a fiery witch with a poison sword?
It could have an emotional effect, but I think you'd have to know what the rest of the story was too. Perhaps the previous owner got killed so gruesomely that this new owner was entirely impervious, or perhaps it was one of those "lost relics in a backwoods area" kind of deals where he lives out in the woods away from civilization, or maybe he just stayed steadfast and when his town emptied it left the town empty for him to live on...
Definitely needs a story to back it up, but it could be excellent!
(and for the record, I agree that everyone's taking your comment too seriously.)
Possibly it is a death so obscure that it basically counts as blank? Assuming that every time the belt takes on a new strength it removes the old one, if the last guy died by falling in a box and accidentally choking on a frog that was in the box, the chances of it happening again before the belt gains a new death is practically non-existant