I don't think it's QUITE as classless as that. Believe me, I am no stranger to utterly shit adaptations of works I love. I'm a huge fan of Avatar: The Last Airbender, and I've seen the film (on my 21st birthday, no less). Maybe it's not totally accurate to compare a cartoon (no matter how good) to a classic piece of literature (even though I haven't read any of the books; Tolkien's writing is too wordy and dry for me), but the rage was there. I was FURIOUS after I saw that movie. I can respect people not liking the trilogy, especially if they're fans of the book.Fox12 said:I think that's a little sad, though. It made a lot of money, it's true, but there are other measures of success, surely? The last film currently has an aggregate score of 60% on rotten tomatoes, and was a major critical let down, especially given the pedigree of the source materials, and of the older films. They messed up the themes and lore that mattered most to Tolkien. The fact that they succeeded in the only way that mattered to Hollywood, the bottom line, is the entire problem. Their priorities are all wrong. They shouldn't be trying to make the most money for the least amount of effort, they should be trying to create a quality piece of art. Sure, it wasn't unsuccessful, but in 10 years no one will even remember the work. To people who respect Tolkien, and who have studied his work in earnest, it feels like this series made a mockery of what he stood for. It would be like if someone made an adaptation of King Leer, and inserted fart jokes everywhere. It's just a little sad, is all.Kolby Jack said:Failure is a pretty broad term, and the way you used it suggested to me that you thought of the trilogy as a failure not just in your eyes, but overall. If you consider it a failure, that's fine, more power to you. It just read like you thought it failed in any way that matters to the creators, which it didn't. That was my only point.
But 60% is still a majority of critics liking it. Sure, any Tolkien fan would want a Tolkien adaptation to get 90% or more because they feel he deserves as much, but I think any Tolkien fan would be glad that these movies are bringing his works to wider audience. I just don't see how these films are a disservice to the man's legacy in any way. The books are still there, as he wrote them, but now people like me who aren't big into books can have a way to enjoy his ideas in another way.