Planet Earth on Blu-Ray

Recommended Videos

the monopoly guy

New member
May 8, 2008
2,276
0
0
Now that Betamax Blu-Ray has won the format wars I decided to put a Blu-Ray player into my new computer. Instead of getting something like Spiderman or Batman or Cars, I decided to get something different. I bought Planet Earth on Blu-Ray.


Elephants aren't really that big


I guess buying Planet earth is no big deal for me, when I was 8 I asked for "he Life of Birds";a 6 VHS box set all about birds and narrated by Sir David Attenborough and as a child my favorite movies were National Geographic nature documentaries. Attenborough also narrates Planet Earth on Blu-Ray, instead of Sigourney Weaver who narrated the TV version and this is a welcome change...for em at least. Attenborough's style of narrating far outdoes most others, instead of talking monotone he adds emotion (well...somewhat) and helps capture the tone of the scene. Still, if you,ve watched "The Life of Birds" or anything else narrated by Attenborough you've pretty much heard it all before as he says the same thing over and over.


"Wild ass. The nomads of the Tibetan Plateau."
"Congratulations Mr. Attenborough, you've done it again...and again...and again..."


There are 4 discs, each one has 2 or 3 different episodes, each episode describing a certain habitat and said habitat's residence. Every episode has at least one "wow" moment-moments that jsut make you go "wow". The orchestral music (performed by The London Orchestra) is truly admirable, and along with David Attenborough's narrations, it never gets bland and repetitive (other thant Attenborough using the same inflection over and over).


*blinks* What the hell was that?

This series is beautiful, plain and simple; there are moments where it looks like you're actually there, swimming over the coral reef yourself; and while this is no new appraisal for a movie, it's true. After watching the freshwater episode I had this sudden urge to go sky diving. The slow motion clip of the shark jumping out of the water after a seal will make you forget that blinking ever existed for about 40 seconds. If there is any one way to show off the power of Blu-Ray, it would be with this series.


Where's my damn parachute?

Buy it
 

neems

New member
Jan 4, 2008
176
0
0
Oddly enough, I also have just recently bought a blu-ray drive for my pc, and I am currently on the 9th episode (of eleven) of Planet Earth - "Shallow Seas".

I have to say, even though not all of the footage is pristine (apparently common with documentaries, where there are various different sources being compiled together), at it's (frequent) best Planet Earth is just jaw droppingly beautiful. And the content is nearly always awesome, regardless of picture quality.

To my mind, this is THE must buy blu-ray disc.

There doesn't appear to be an option to have Sigourney Weaver's narration though.
 

the monopoly guy

New member
May 8, 2008
2,276
0
0

the man slays me


He's my favorite narrator, and he's been knighted. Has Weaver been knighted? No, no she has not. I was absolutly giddy when I found out he narrated it because I thought he died.
 

Tanthalos

New member
Mar 25, 2008
203
0
0
I am much more interested in whether they give you the option. If there are two versions of something I should be able to choose between them. I personally do not care between the two choices but if there are two different audio tracks I want the ability to choose.
 

ThaBenMan

Mandalorian Buddha
Mar 6, 2008
3,682
0
0
I think I just figured out what I'm getting my dad for his birthday next month (he got a PS3 awhile ago).

I caught a few episodes on tv, it's an awesome show, and I bet it's just amazing on Blu-Ray.
 

the monopoly guy

New member
May 8, 2008
2,276
0
0
ThaBenMan said:
I think I just figured out what I'm getting my dad for his birthday next month (he got a PS3 awhile ago).

I caught a few episodes on tv, it's an awesome show, and I bet it's just amazing on Blu-Ray.
Don't forget the parachute and skydiving lessons. And glad I could help?
 

The Wooster

King Snap
Jul 15, 2008
15,305
0
0
j-e-f-f-e-r-s said:
Tanthalos said:
I am much more interested in whether they give you the option. If there are two versions of something I should be able to choose between them. I personally do not care between the two choices but if there are two different audio tracks I want the ability to choose.
Yeah, but this isn't really a choice. Much as I love her, Attenborough > Weaver by a million and one. They could have God narrating, and Sir David would still be the better choice. His voice is just perfect for documentaries like this.
What if they got Morgan 'Overlord of the penguins' Freeman to narrate?

That being said. Good review. I'm going to rent this over the weekend.
 

the monopoly guy

New member
May 8, 2008
2,276
0
0
Xiado said:
Yes, it was really good, but Attenborough is easily the better narrator, so buy the BBC copy
The American Copy is narrated by him too, or it is if you order it from PBS at least I doubt it's any different from the discovery channel or a store
 

the monopoly guy

New member
May 8, 2008
2,276
0
0
TrevorOfCrete said:
nice to have somthing a little less mainstream reviewed. Good review also.
I don't like mainstream. To overrated, to much current. I like the little streams. Good trout fishing. Wait...what?

This is the must have Blu-Ray, that is, until they release Star Wars on Blu-Ray and Han Solo shoots first.