Ganado_Headshot said:
Left 4 Dead is a good game but it lacks so much, four campaigns, I mean come on for real?
I agree, L4D was an alright online co-op shooter but it isn't particularly long lived and it doesn't feel like a true zombie game. Granted, the AI director supposedly mixes things up a bit but I often found this to be more frustrating than refreshing (oddly enough, encountering three tanks and a witch in the space of five minutes is fairly annoying), in retrospect I think Valve should have ditched the random events crap and stuck with a more predictable set up (as it is most campaigns turn into disorganised disasters by the second level, they should have gone for what I once heard someone call 'organised chaos' that being where it feels like everything is manic and chaotic but it is in fact well planned and rehearsed).
L4D didn't feel like a zombie game for the simple reason of you kill too many zombies and too quickly, zombies are supposed to be extremely tough and unstoppable, killing reams of them with a single, not very well placed shotgun shell kills the threat that pose along with any tension or fear. Dead Rising also had a monumental number of zombies but each zombie was considerably more difficult to dispatch which kept it in check with the zombie style (notice how in movies the survivors never have to kill that many zombies and that every single one is a challange to down).
I have always loved the House of the Dead series for the fact that I love the experience of being in an arcade to play them (the plastic shotgun/uzi makes everything feel much better), I liked all of them quite a lot (and they are fairly simmilar) so I can't honestly pick between them (if pushed I'll say Overkill).