Multiplayer would never have worked with infinite, the vigors would have had to be eliminated completely, as half of them would be instant death for another person if they were to land. The skyrails also wouldn't work, it'd just be people knocking each other off à la Assassin's Creed Dogpile[footnote]You know, when one person makes a kill, then is killed by their follower, who is killed by theirs, etc, etc, all in one spot on the map.[/footnote] because skyrail attacks are auto-targeted. The guns are weak enough that it would probably work if it were just a shooter, though.
As Hazabaza1 suggested, a horde/survival mode would fit the bill perfectly for bioshock gameplay.
As Hazabaza1 suggested, a horde/survival mode would fit the bill perfectly for bioshock gameplay.