Poll: Decisions, Decisions...

Recommended Videos

jboking

New member
Oct 10, 2008
2,694
0
0
I recently found myself in quite the predicament. While playing Fallout 3, my four year old 20gig PS3 finally Yellow Lighted on me. I felt like I was standing over a good friend's corpse. I went through four years of brand new gaming with that giant black dog and spent even more time going through my back-catalog of PS2 games. So I did the only thing that made sense, I went to Sony's support page and looked at how much it would cost to repair: $150 - not including any other taxes they can pin on me. I thought that was it, $150 or nothing, but they made me another offer. For $119 they would just trash my old system and send me a new smaller ps3 with a 120gig hard drive. I have the money for either option, but I'm stuck trying to decide if the emotional attachment I have to that old beast is enough to outweigh the allure of a newer model. It feels like I'm trading in my wife. A friend also had another suggestion for me that can be summed up as "Screw the PS3!" He recommends that I trash it and sell all my old games. Then, use that and whatever spare money I have to purchase the new slim 360 that is coming out.

While I know the choice is ultimately mine, I'm wondering what my fellow escapists would do in this scenario. Also, sharing stories of system failure seems appropriate.
 

Skorpyo

Average Person Extraordinaire!
May 2, 2010
2,284
0
0
In my experience, when a console dies once, it will die again.

Get the new PS3. You already have made the commitment, and the new model will undoubtedly work much better.
 

jboking

New member
Oct 10, 2008
2,694
0
0
Miles Tormani said:
My vote depends entirely on the answer to one question.

Do you still have a working PS2?
No I don't have a working PS2 anymore. My old one blew up...fun times, fun times.
pretentiousname01 said:
what do the majority of your real friends have?
a lot of them have 360's, a few have PS3's, and even fewer have gaming PC's. I have a working gaming PC, so I suppose the other option was to say "fuck consoles!" and become a hardcore PC gamer.
isn't the 20gig bc?
yes, yes it was. I loved playing some Jak and Daxter on that thing.
 

vance32

New member
Aug 5, 2009
89
0
0
ps3 in my opinion its kinda bad in graphics my old xbox broke so i got a ps3 and i got fallout 3 for the ps3 and loved it then i got a elite and used my old fallout 3 and the graphics are so better so get the 360
 

Miumaru

New member
May 5, 2010
1,765
0
0
Id go with 360. Atleast they send you a new one for free if you RROD.
 

jboking

New member
Oct 10, 2008
2,694
0
0
vance32 said:
ps3 in my opinion its kinda bad in graphics my old xbox broke so i got a ps3 and i got fallout 3 for the ps3 and loved it then i got a elite and used my old fallout 3 and the graphics are so better so get the 360
You see, I mooch off of my friends 360 during the summer. I'm constantly jumping back and forth between the 360 and PS3. I have yet to notice a major tip in graphics towards either party. For each ME2 on the 360 I find an Uncharted 2 on the PS3.
 

pretentiousname01

New member
Sep 30, 2009
476
0
0
jboking said:
Did you also get cranky with them on the phone. usually you can get a little more out of them to "satisfy the customer"

However as most of your friends have a 360 I'd consider going that way.

Playing with your friends is the name of this generation. I also know gamestop is doing a 200$ for any ps3 system trade in. Maybe send yours back for the slim 120, then trade it in for 200. Depending on how long they tell you it will take.

If you decide to keep ps3. Definitely get it fixed not replaced. Backwards compatibility is worth 30$

Also as a note, you can get almost any laptop harddrive to replace the 20gig if you find yourself running low on space.
 

Miles Tormani

New member
Jul 30, 2008
471
0
0
jboking said:
No I don't have a working PS2 anymore. My old one blew up...fun times, fun times.
In that case, I would go for repairing your old PS3, unless you have the spare funds to get a new PS2. Especially since you could easily upgrade your old one with a standard 500 GB SATA HDD. (EDIT: I think it's a standard one...)

If you do get a new PS2, though, keep in mind that while the new systems aren't backwards compatible with PS2 games, they still for whatever reason have the memory card utility work with both PS1 and PS2 cards. So you can still make a bunch of virtual cards on the hard drive, and then transfer saves to and from a physical memory card as needed.

Of course, you would need the memory card transfer accessory thing in that case...
 

vance32

New member
Aug 5, 2009
89
0
0
well i really caint tell the difference between a 360 and a ps3 besides fallout theres a weird line between every object