Poll: Evolution Yay or Nah?

Recommended Videos

AlexNora

New member
Mar 7, 2011
207
0
0
lotr rocks 0 said:
AlexNora said:
as for evidence id look at all of it really closely because most of it is highly exaggerated if not blatant lies.
yeah.... no.

You may occasionally get a scientist with some kind of agenda trying to push things a certain way, but scientific publications are all peer-reviewed and would be thrown out if there was any clear bias in it. also any scientist can feel free to repeat any experiment performed if they are skeptical about it and they can call bullshit on it if necessary.
that's great and all but what if all your peers are just as willing to lie think about about it..
 

x360ryan

New member
Jul 6, 2011
2
0
0
Even religion itself is evolving, think about it. First it said this now its changed to being accepting of gay people, then the big bang theory and now religions adapting to survive the new threat of evolution.
No offense to anyone.
 

Sight Unseen

The North Remembers
Nov 18, 2009
1,063
0
0
AlexNora said:
lotr rocks 0 said:
AlexNora said:
as for evidence id look at all of it really closely because most of it is highly exaggerated if not blatant lies.
yeah.... no.

You may occasionally get a scientist with some kind of agenda trying to push things a certain way, but scientific publications are all peer-reviewed and would be thrown out if there was any clear bias in it. also any scientist can feel free to repeat any experiment performed if they are skeptical about it and they can call bullshit on it if necessary.
that's great and all but what if all your peers are just as willing to lie think about about it..
That's some pretty intense conspiracy stuff you've got going there. Can you imagine how hard it would be to completely cover up any contradicting evidence to evolutionary theory and also prevent any upcoming scientist in practically any field of biological sciences from seeing the truth? It would be practically impossible to keep the truth a secret if the millions upon millions of facts that supported evolution were all made up, someone would fuck up somewhere and ruin the whole thing.

It would have to be a worldwide conspiracy among every university and major scientific corporation in the world.

And ultimately, what would be the point of it? Evolutionary theory provides useful tools for many fields of science, what would be the use in a worldwide conspiracy designed to provide useful and logical explanations for the universe?
 

TKIR

New member
Sep 7, 2011
20
0
0
AlexNora said:
as for evidence id look at all of it really closely because most of it is highly exaggerated if not blatant lies.
Please share what evidence you think is highly exaggerated or a blatant lie.
 

Guitarmasterx7

Day Pig
Mar 16, 2009
3,871
0
0
masterbazza said:
I'm a christian
i also believe that evolution is a real thing
i don't believe that we evolved from apes
i believe that we began to evolve from the moment god created us
think about it
Well good for you. Just to clarify, you are aware that even people who DO believe in evolution don't believe we evolved from modern apes, right? If so, go about your day. If you were trying to present a contradictory opinion without outright saying it, then you didn't really express it in the right way and I'm not quite sure you understand the boundary you're trying to push with that statement.

OT: yes. The evolution debate has at this point become the modern day version of the discovery that the earth is round. People are slow to accept it is because of lingering religious dogma and it's taking a little bit longer to become widely accepted because it's far easier to sail around the world than it is to dig up the seemingly infinite number of fossils necessary to completely prove without a shadow of a doubt that evolution is real to somebody who is actively in denial about it. Not that we haven't been digging, mind.
 

Kolby Jack

Come at me scrublord, I'm ripped
Apr 29, 2011
2,518
0
0
lotr rocks 0 said:
Jack the Potato said:
Is it so hard for people to respect other people's beliefs? I've yet to meet a creationist who 's belief made them less than worthwhile. An asshole will be an asshole regardless of whether or not he believes the earth was made by God 6000 years ago or coalesced from space rocks 4.5 billion years ago. A person's actions determine his worth, not his beliefs.
I don't have a problem with people believing what they want to believe, but I hate when people are willfully ignorant about things. If you do your homework piece together the facts and come to the conclusion that evolution guided by a creator, then that's fine all the power to you, but if you want other people to believe you you'd better be ready to support your opinion with facts.

It's people who consistently ignore the facts, or worse, keep using the same arguments that have been refuted hundreds of times that piss me off. Espescially if they have the audacity to say that I'm a bad person for being an atheist because I lack morality or some crap like that. but that's for another topic.
As do I. Ignorance should be fought at every opportunity. And yes, someone who tells you you are a bad person for being an Atheist is obviously not that open-minded a guy. My brother is an Atheist, and while my Mom, who is a devout Christian (though not a creationist,) believes it is just a phase, she doesn't force the issue. She prays for him while letting him decide for himself. Close-minded people exist on both sides. The thing is, you can't prove creationists wrong. According to their beliefs, nothing is beyond the scope of God's power, so if they say "God did it" it's pretty tough to convince them otherwise if their beliefs are strong enough. My point is, all these people on the Escapist who make fun of creationists and call them ignorant aren't really helping anyone.
 

LadyRhian

New member
May 13, 2010
1,245
0
0
titankore said:
Religion is a belief, science is made up with facts. Calling evolution a theory is just shorthand for saying "We are not sure about every minute detail yet but the general idea is correct".

It's like the theory of gravity we know gravity exists we have a basic idea on how to measure it and it's effects but we don't know EVERYTHING about it yet so it is still a theory.
Ironically, we have more evidence for evolution than for gravity!
 

LadyRhian

New member
May 13, 2010
1,245
0
0
Guitarmasterx7 said:
masterbazza said:
I'm a christian
i also believe that evolution is a real thing
i don't believe that we evolved from apes
i believe that we began to evolve from the moment god created us
think about it
Well good for you. Just to clarify, you are aware that even people who DO believe in evolution don't believe we evolved from modern apes, right? If so, go about your day. If you were trying to present a contradictory opinion without outright saying it, then you didn't really express it in the right way and I'm not quite sure you understand the boundary you're trying to push with that statement.

OT: yes. The evolution debate has at this point become the modern day version of the discovery that the earth is round. People are slow to accept it is because of lingering religious dogma and it's taking a little bit longer to become widely accepted because it's far easier to sail around the world than it is to dig up the seemingly infinite number of fossils necessary to completely prove without a shadow of a doubt that evolution is real to somebody who is actively in denial about it. Not that we haven't been digging, mind.
People never really believed the earth wasn't round. That was a myth. Sailors knew if you sailed over the horizon, the effect on your view of land meant the surface of the earth was curved, not flat. Ironically, that myth is supposed to make us modern-day people feel we are smarter than people used to be, kind of a "LOL! Look how wrong they were in the bad old days!" Check out Snopes for the truth.

octafish said:
I believe in De-evolution, does that count?

Q. ARE WE NOT MEN?
We are DEVO! ;)

But no, there is no such thing as "De-Evolution". Things/Animals/Microbes/Whatever don't always get more complex. Sometimes it goes the opposite way, like the evolution of viruses. They jettisoned their own ways of reproducing to co-opt the reproduction of the cells they invade. It actually made the virus less complex- all they are is DNA, a coat around it, and a way of "injecting" that DNA into a cell. Once inside the Cell, the virus DNA takes over and makes your cell make copies of itself. Many, many copies of itself. So many that the invaded cell ruptures, and releases the copies back into your body. Wash, rinse and repeat for all the "new" copied viruses.

Evolution has no direction. Thus, there is no such thing as "De-evolution". There are plenty of variations in humans. One set of people have evolved to be immune to AIDS (actually, have evolved to be immune to similar type diseases and ailments. It confers more than just immunity to AIDS, but that's the common expression of those genes in this day and age), while others are immune to plaque buildup in the veins and arteries and heart disease (common in Italy, from what I remember, but I think this also crops up elsewhere). Both are not present in most of the population, but if AIDS and Heart Disease remain common, you can expect those genes to spread, as long as both AIDS and Heart Disease kill people off before they can reproduce. (In before someone says AIDS is a gay disease- not any more it isn't. Isn't it time you come into the modern day and not the 80's/90's?)

If you say "I believe in/accept De-Evolution", you can just take the "de" off. You accept evolution. Same with Micro/Macro of what have you. And "believe" isn't the right word. Accept is better. You don't believe in it, you merely accept the evidence that it happens. Evolution is a FACT and A THEORY. The fact is, it happens. The theory explains how.
 

Alleged_Alec

New member
Sep 2, 2008
796
0
0
Seriously? Six percent does not accept this theory?


Blegh. Why are people arguing against a non-controversial theory? It's stupid, annoying and makes me want to hit stuff.
 

octafish

New member
Apr 23, 2010
5,134
0
0
LadyRhian said:
Guitarmasterx7 said:
masterbazza said:
I'm a christian
i also believe that evolution is a real thing
i don't believe that we evolved from apes
i believe that we began to evolve from the moment god created us
think about it
Well good for you. Just to clarify, you are aware that even people who DO believe in evolution don't believe we evolved from modern apes, right? If so, go about your day. If you were trying to present a contradictory opinion without outright saying it, then you didn't really express it in the right way and I'm not quite sure you understand the boundary you're trying to push with that statement.

OT: yes. The evolution debate has at this point become the modern day version of the discovery that the earth is round. People are slow to accept it is because of lingering religious dogma and it's taking a little bit longer to become widely accepted because it's far easier to sail around the world than it is to dig up the seemingly infinite number of fossils necessary to completely prove without a shadow of a doubt that evolution is real to somebody who is actively in denial about it. Not that we haven't been digging, mind.
People never really believed the earth wasn't round. That was a myth. Sailors knew if you sailed over the horizon, the effect on your view of land meant the surface of the earth was curved, not flat. Ironically, that myth is supposed to make us modern-day people feel we are smarter than people used to be, kind of a "LOL! Look how wrong they were in the bad old days!" Check out Snopes for the truth.

octafish said:
I believe in De-evolution, does that count?

Q. ARE WE NOT MEN?
We are DEVO! ;)

But no, there is no such thing as "De-Evolution". Things/Animals/Microbes/Whatever don't always get more complex. Sometimes it goes the opposite way, like the evolution of viruses. They jettisoned their own ways of reproducing to co-opt the reproduction of the cells they invade. It actually made the virus less complex- all they are is DNA, a coat around it, and a way of "injecting" that DNA into a cell. Once inside the Cell, the virus DNA takes over and makes your cell make copies of itself. Many, many copies of itself. So many that the invaded cell ruptures, and releases the copies back into your body. Wash, rinse and repeat for all the "new" copied viruses.

Evolution has no direction. Thus, there is no such thing as "De-evolution". There are plenty of variations in humans. One set of people have evolved to be immune to AIDS (actually, have evolved to be immune to similar type diseases and ailments. It confers more than just immunity to AIDS, but that's the common expression of those genes in this day and age), while others are immune to plaque buildup in the veins and arteries and heart disease (common in Italy, from what I remember, but I think this also crops up elsewhere). Both are not present in most of the population, but if AIDS and Heart Disease remain common, you can expect those genes to spread, as long as both AIDS and Heart Disease kill people off before they can reproduce. (In before someone says AIDS is a gay disease- not any more it isn't. Isn't it time you come into the modern day and not the 80's/90's?)
Hey, I'm just a spud, not a scientist.
 

LadyRhian

New member
May 13, 2010
1,245
0
0
octafish said:
LadyRhian said:
Guitarmasterx7 said:
masterbazza said:
I'm a christian
i also believe that evolution is a real thing
i don't believe that we evolved from apes
i believe that we began to evolve from the moment god created us
think about it
Well good for you. Just to clarify, you are aware that even people who DO believe in evolution don't believe we evolved from modern apes, right? If so, go about your day. If you were trying to present a contradictory opinion without outright saying it, then you didn't really express it in the right way and I'm not quite sure you understand the boundary you're trying to push with that statement.

OT: yes. The evolution debate has at this point become the modern day version of the discovery that the earth is round. People are slow to accept it is because of lingering religious dogma and it's taking a little bit longer to become widely accepted because it's far easier to sail around the world than it is to dig up the seemingly infinite number of fossils necessary to completely prove without a shadow of a doubt that evolution is real to somebody who is actively in denial about it. Not that we haven't been digging, mind.
People never really believed the earth wasn't round. That was a myth. Sailors knew if you sailed over the horizon, the effect on your view of land meant the surface of the earth was curved, not flat. Ironically, that myth is supposed to make us modern-day people feel we are smarter than people used to be, kind of a "LOL! Look how wrong they were in the bad old days!" Check out Snopes for the truth.

octafish said:
I believe in De-evolution, does that count?

Q. ARE WE NOT MEN?
We are DEVO! ;)

But no, there is no such thing as "De-Evolution". Things/Animals/Microbes/Whatever don't always get more complex. Sometimes it goes the opposite way, like the evolution of viruses. They jettisoned their own ways of reproducing to co-opt the reproduction of the cells they invade. It actually made the virus less complex- all they are is DNA, a coat around it, and a way of "injecting" that DNA into a cell. Once inside the Cell, the virus DNA takes over and makes your cell make copies of itself. Many, many copies of itself. So many that the invaded cell ruptures, and releases the copies back into your body. Wash, rinse and repeat for all the "new" copied viruses.

Evolution has no direction. Thus, there is no such thing as "De-evolution". There are plenty of variations in humans. One set of people have evolved to be immune to AIDS (actually, have evolved to be immune to similar type diseases and ailments. It confers more than just immunity to AIDS, but that's the common expression of those genes in this day and age), while others are immune to plaque buildup in the veins and arteries and heart disease (common in Italy, from what I remember, but I think this also crops up elsewhere). Both are not present in most of the population, but if AIDS and Heart Disease remain common, you can expect those genes to spread, as long as both AIDS and Heart Disease kill people off before they can reproduce. (In before someone says AIDS is a gay disease- not any more it isn't. Isn't it time you come into the modern day and not the 80's/90's?)
Hey, I'm just a spud, not a scientist.
Neither am I, actually! (Writer, tbh, and my degree is in English). But I paid attention in college, and continue to read science blogs like The Panda's Thumb and Pharyngula.
 

Kolby Jack

Come at me scrublord, I'm ripped
Apr 29, 2011
2,518
0
0
Alleged_Alec said:
Seriously? Six percent does not accept this theory?


Blegh. Why are people arguing against a non-controversial theory? It's stupid, annoying and makes me want to hit stuff.
Because it is controversial? If it challenges someone's beliefs, then it must be controversial. And hitting stuff never helps. It just results in property damage or arrest.
 

Sight Unseen

The North Remembers
Nov 18, 2009
1,063
0
0
LadyRhian said:
octafish said:
LadyRhian said:
Guitarmasterx7 said:
masterbazza said:
I'm a christian
i also believe that evolution is a real thing
i don't believe that we evolved from apes
i believe that we began to evolve from the moment god created us
think about it
Well good for you. Just to clarify, you are aware that even people who DO believe in evolution don't believe we evolved from modern apes, right? If so, go about your day. If you were trying to present a contradictory opinion without outright saying it, then you didn't really express it in the right way and I'm not quite sure you understand the boundary you're trying to push with that statement.

OT: yes. The evolution debate has at this point become the modern day version of the discovery that the earth is round. People are slow to accept it is because of lingering religious dogma and it's taking a little bit longer to become widely accepted because it's far easier to sail around the world than it is to dig up the seemingly infinite number of fossils necessary to completely prove without a shadow of a doubt that evolution is real to somebody who is actively in denial about it. Not that we haven't been digging, mind.
People never really believed the earth wasn't round. That was a myth. Sailors knew if you sailed over the horizon, the effect on your view of land meant the surface of the earth was curved, not flat. Ironically, that myth is supposed to make us modern-day people feel we are smarter than people used to be, kind of a "LOL! Look how wrong they were in the bad old days!" Check out Snopes for the truth.

octafish said:
I believe in De-evolution, does that count?

Q. ARE WE NOT MEN?
We are DEVO! ;)

But no, there is no such thing as "De-Evolution". Things/Animals/Microbes/Whatever don't always get more complex. Sometimes it goes the opposite way, like the evolution of viruses. They jettisoned their own ways of reproducing to co-opt the reproduction of the cells they invade. It actually made the virus less complex- all they are is DNA, a coat around it, and a way of "injecting" that DNA into a cell. Once inside the Cell, the virus DNA takes over and makes your cell make copies of itself. Many, many copies of itself. So many that the invaded cell ruptures, and releases the copies back into your body. Wash, rinse and repeat for all the "new" copied viruses.

Evolution has no direction. Thus, there is no such thing as "De-evolution". There are plenty of variations in humans. One set of people have evolved to be immune to AIDS (actually, have evolved to be immune to similar type diseases and ailments. It confers more than just immunity to AIDS, but that's the common expression of those genes in this day and age), while others are immune to plaque buildup in the veins and arteries and heart disease (common in Italy, from what I remember, but I think this also crops up elsewhere). Both are not present in most of the population, but if AIDS and Heart Disease remain common, you can expect those genes to spread, as long as both AIDS and Heart Disease kill people off before they can reproduce. (In before someone says AIDS is a gay disease- not any more it isn't. Isn't it time you come into the modern day and not the 80's/90's?)
Hey, I'm just a spud, not a scientist.
Neither am I, actually! (Writer, tbh, and my degree is in English). But I paid attention in college, and continue to read science blogs like The Panda's Thumb and Pharyngula.
I'm a scientist! well... an aspiring one... In my 4th year in a biotechnology and chemical engineering course :p
 

blaize2010

New member
Sep 17, 2010
230
0
0
stupid question. everyone knows that steve jobs and superman went to mars 11 billion years ago and cloned everything there, then began placing the random organisms on earth for centuries when one species starts getting too smart. then when the dinosaurs started getting too out of control to handle,they made the stock market literally crash into the earth. then superman used his heat vision to take out the ozone layer to win a bet against al gore. and that is history, my friends, you're welcome. oh wait, now i know what you're thinking, superman and steve jobs couldn't have gone to mars 11 billion years ago, our sun is only six billion years old. well, i have news for you. CARL SAGAN LIED. AND DON'T ARGUE WITH ME OVER WIBBLY WOBBLY TIMEY WIMEY STUFF. OR I'LL FIND YOU. AND EDUCATE YOU. WITH MY FISTS. EVERYTHING IS INFINITY YEARS OLD. THAT IS TATOOED ON MY FISTS. BUT NOT MY HANDS. IT KIND OF HURT. I DIDN'T ABBREVIATE AT ALL
-message funded by the church of the flying spaghetti monster
-COFSM funded by the catholic church
-Catholic church funded by The Illuminati