Poll: Favorite Pokemon Game

[drbarno]

I'd say Heartgold/Soulsilver for me. Mainly because I liked all the little extra's they placed into them. My only gripe is that they didn't add to the story in any way more, unlike Firered/Leafgreen, which had an extra Team rocket encounter. The lack of story in that really shows compared to the Diamond/Pearl/Platinum (the other Gen IV games)

While Black and White did a lot to try and make it seem refreshing, I just didn't find it as fun, maybe it's the nostaglia clouding my vision, maybe it's not.

 

[Reincarnatedwolfgod]

Also, am I the only person who still enjoys the anime, even the newer episodes? I'm rewatching the entire series from scratch (halfway through the Orange Islands arc right now) as a bit of nostalgia, and having seen episodes from the Diamond/Pearl arcs a while back I can't say there's anything bad about them, really. Why do the later episodes get so much hate when really they're just as good as the early ones?

do you know there a "just as good as the early ones"? ... because there are all the same and they never changed. you may not mind the fact they never innovate and just do the same old crap but most people feel the show has gotten stale and/or they grew out of it.
in my case it's both. i lost interest on the show and it just keeps using the same formula

the formula
meet ____ professor
cheesy side stories/catch the occasional Pokemon
get a badge
repeat 7 more times
more side stories
elite 4
go to new area
repeat same exact again formula again(Lather, rinse, repeat)

what makes the games different from the show is it at least improves it self ever generation

 

[Wolfenbarg]

Gold and Silver seemed to refine the formula to a level I considered near perfection. It had a completely different feel from the first game somehow, the aesthetic combined with the overall technical differences really added up. However, despite how the TC may think saying they're all the same makes you look like an "idiot", it really has to be said. The games following Gold and Silver were obviously refined even further, but the fact that it was the same plot and the Pokemon started showing signs of complete unoriginality is why I could never call one of the new games better. Nintendo does love to reinvent their franchises, but they never remake the exact same game wholesale. They almost always have new and interesting mechanics behind each game.

Yeah, because Gold and Silver were full to the brim with originality.
A pinecone, a cow, a giraffe, a reskinned dog, a spider, a bigger spider, a ladybug, and a deformed reindeer are all super original. Those are just the few I can think of off the top of my head, but the Pokemon aren't getting unoriginal.
Face it, the Pokemon have always been unoriginal.

You're completely missing the point. They were original in their own universe. Being based on something in our world or being a creation that would seem incredibly obvious to us isn't unoriginal, if that's the case, then the only creatures they could create would be based on creatures you could only see in an acid trip. The problem is that after a certain point, they started looking back on their own creations and copying from them. When you get to the point that you have to start ripping yourself off, and that is the sole source of your innovation in a title, your game is beyond stale and trite.

Except none of that happened, save 1-2 Pokemon in each generation. Go through the list of generations, and tell me how many copies of Pokemon there are. Especially in Gens 4/5, where there are maximun 5 Pokemon that are rehashes of old ones.

Except that that always happens. Entire concepts were just lifted from earlier generations, reskinned, and called brand new. Some they take great care to make sure they feel unique (the starters are always well crafted), but too many others spark a feeling of deja vu.

 

[ninjapenguin981]

Pearl was the one I spent most time on, and had the most fun with so it'll have to be Diamond/Pearl/Platinum.

 

[Everian]

1/ SoulSilver/HeartGold - MY 2 old Favs remade, which was the only reason i forked out for a new Nintend DSI XL

2/Black/White - Love all the changes they have made so far and looking forward to whats to come.

3/Silver/Gold - Loved these games and played them alot, pity my data got currupted and had to wipe em.

4/Red/Blue/Yellow - Classics

ETC - Never played the others. stopped before FireRed/LeafGreen Came out and then went back when SS/HG were out.

 

[kortin]

I dont have 1 favorite, I have 3. My favorites are Crystal, Ruby, and Diamond.

 

[icame]

Pokemon reskin #747678: Gold edition is my personal favorite.

 

[Sovvolf]

Blue, it brings back so many good memories. It also has great replayability...

Speaking of Pokemon, I always thought you avatar was a Bulbasaur.

And yeah, mines Red it was the first I ever played, so its probably blind nostalgia but its not just that. its that I haven't played many since then. Second place would probably go to gold and silver though. Other than that, I can't remember playing any other Pokemon games. Temped to by the new black and white but I think I've out grown Pokemon a little... Still I'm very tempted.

 

[Jark212]

Blue, it brings back so many good memories. It also has great replayability...

Speaking of Pokemon, I always thought you avatar was a Bulbasaur.

Nope, he's just the Frog-God of happiness:

 

[StoneCutter]

I think I'll have to go with Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald. I really liked that it was mostly new pokemon, and a lot of the designs and concepts seemed really original (ludicolo, numel). The game also did a great job giving each city its own unique feel, whereas some of the other games work less towards distinguishing towns from each other. And the contests, while kinda pointless, were actually kinda fun.

Just started White though, and if these posts are any indication, I might have to switch my vote.

 

[Sovvolf]

snip

Mine dreams have now been squashed.

 

[EHKOS]

I like them all!!!! Except DPP. They felt...off. B&W feel off too but not as bad.

 

[Giantpanda602]

1. R/S/E
2. HG/SS
3. B/W
4. G/S/C
5. FR/LG
6. R/B/Y
7. D/P/Pt

 

[Macedon]

I started out with Red and Yellow, but I have to say that my favorite Pokemon game was Leafgreen.

 

[Koroviev]

I really like Black/White. Close second would be HeartGold/SoulSilver.

 

[elbrandino]

Gold, Silver, and Crystal are still my favorites. Red and Blue and Black and White come in second.

 

[Shock and Awe]

Ruby for me, modern mechanics with the last generation to have cool looking pokemon.

 

[Cheesus333]

Trend suggests that Pokémon games got progressively worse and then better. But if you take into account that a lot of these votes for the earlier titles will be based on childhood nostalgia, then it might look a little different.

 

[AugustFall]

I loved S/G and HG/SS. I felt like they had the best thing with 2 regions and a great selection of pokemon and I was super annoyed they didn't continue with the multiple region thing.

But I love Black I love all the mechanics and how pretty it is. I love the fact that all the pokemon are new it really creates the same sense of wonder as when I played R/B for the first time.

 

[BanthaFodder]

I think either G/S/C or B/W
I'm playing through White right now and the last time I had this much fun with a Pokemon game was when I first started playing Silver on my purple see-through Game Boy Color