Poll: Game of Thrones as an Anime (Animation) show

[snowpuppy]

I had an overwhelming feeling of no, but thinking about it... Yeah, I'd watch it. It would need a certain animation style.

 

[TheYellowCellPhone]

It's like arguing whether the Lord of the Rings was better as an animated movie or as Peter Jackson's trilogy. An animation allowed pretty unfeasible scenes and unique character designs to come to life without donning rubber suits or abusing CG graphics. But Peter Jackson's trilogy showed that it's still possible to have enormous battles and make it look good and exciting without sacrificing creative assets.

No real right answer, but I think most of us think the live action show is pretty faithful and isn't falling too short of what we wanted.

There is an animated version of Lord of the Rings. It was out before the Peter Jackson version too. Look it up it's quite fascinating.

That was sort of the point of my post. Never actually seen it, I just know it exists.