Poll: GTA 4 or Fallout 3

[TheMasterGL16]

Ok, the next game I play is down to GTA 4 or Fallout 3...

Both on steam, one or the other...

GO!!!!

I know enough about both, I know I'd like both...

I don't wanna hear any of that, "depends on what you like crap" I like most games and am sure either choice would rock, just wanna know about what people, preferable who played both have to say.

 

[Sassafrass]

Played both, picked Fallout 3.
Better world to explore and a more jaw dropping experience.

 

[speedbat]

fallout 3 all the way, yes GTA4 is fun, but in fallout you have huge guns and can destroy a whole city, you can make your own weapons, level up, get different stats, play through as nice and then on another file or something play through as evil... long story short,

Fallout 3 is 100X better than GTA 4

 

[The_Healer]

Played both, picked Fallout 3.
Better world to explore and a more jaw dropping experience.

Holy shit! different avatar!

OT: Agree with this man

I dislike the new avatar; it scares and confuses me.

OT: I concur!

 

[Sassafrass]

Played both, picked Fallout 3.
Better world to explore and a more jaw dropping experience.

Holy shit! different avatar!

OT: Agree with this man

Do you like it?
It's the third time I've had someone say that since changing it.

I dislike the new avatar; it scares and confuses me.

OT: I concur!

Hey, you scared me with the Dumbledore/Potter thing that was in your mind...

I'm just returning the favour.

 

[Chicago Ted]

For PC? Fallout 3 hands down.

 

[irishdelinquent]

Fallout 3, by a mile. I literally had to force myself to finish GTA IV.

 

[sunami88]

Played both, no contest: Fallout 3. It's the better game in every regard, IMO.

 

[PaulyWalnuts]

Fallout 3 is one of the best games I've played.

 

[Sassafrass]

Played both, picked Fallout 3.
Better world to explore and a more jaw dropping experience.

Holy shit! different avatar!

OT: Agree with this man

Do you like it?
It's the third time I've had someone say that since changing it.

It's pretty cool. I'm just waiting for the last 600 posts, then BAM! The best avatar EVER

Why, thank you.

But for some reason, it keeps reverting back to the old one for me on my profile screen...
It's weird.

 

[thenuminator]

fallout 3 for the win I didn't even finish GTA4

 

[RaNDM G]

I'd pick GTA 4. Even with mods, Fallout 3 was just too boring for me...

I should probably run now...

 

[TheMasterGL16]

lol, well, it looks like Fallout 3... but I AM glad SOME people said GTA 4... I mean it's only second on the list for me, I'll probably buy it after I beat fallout 3.

 

[Blazing Steel]

Fallout 3 GOTY. Hands down. No compation.

 

[Celestialum]

I haven't played through GTA IV, but I feel like I've finished every little quest and special item in Fallout 3, besides two of its DLCs. Though I have to say, the ones I have played, I've loved. Broken Steel and Point Lookout are both brilliant.

 

[Crazyshak48]

Fallout 3, by a LONG shot. Fallout 3 is one of those gaming black holes that just sucks in my social life and keeps me anchored to my computer. GTA IV, on the other hand, I wish I had never bought, never could bring myself to finish, and recently traded in for Prototype.

I think you can see my reasoning here.

 

[SonicKoala]

I love both games, but Fallout 3 is the better game. The only thing GTA IV has going for it is it has better graphics - the multiplayer is pretty fun, too, but Fallout 3 has a lot more to it.

 

[garfoldsomeoneelse]

I finished GTAIV simply because I felt like it would be a waste not to finish it after all the time I'd sunk into it. After that, I barely touched it, and when I decided to pop it in once in a while for nostalgia's sake, I'd find myself putting it down rather quickly.

I finished Fallout 3 because I was deeply engrossed in it, and wanted to see what happened next. Besides, the battle near the end was so amazing that the rest of the game would have been worth enduring if it was nothing but ten straight hours of Pong. Oh, and then I went on the complete it two more times, and I only stay away from it because I'm afraid of getting sucked in again, as I can't afford to lose any sleep, what with work being so hectic lately.

 

[Klagermeister]

Is that even a question? Fallout 3 for sure.
Easily hundreds of dungeons and miniquests pepper the game, along with slow-motion "BOOM! HEADSHOT!" moments... WHENEVER YOU WANT!
Get Fallout 3. If you got GTA IV instead, the whole of Escapist would /facepalm.

 

[Baggie]

Fallout 3. GTA4 was okay, but Fallout 3 was excellent.