Poll: GTA IV or RDR?

[MoNKeyYy]

I know, I know, vs thread, but trust me I actually have a point to this one. I suspect the voting will go a certain way and after a while I'll add to this post detailing my actual reason for asking this question and a little rant to go with it. Please post your reason why you voted the way you did as well, as I suspect it will help with what I tentatively call my research.

EDIT: Disappearing poll, fuck that. Let's try this again.

EDIT 2: Link to actual poll: http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/9.304077-Poll-GTA-IV-or-RDR

 

[Shoggoth2588]

I actually got through the GTAIV story mode. Red Dead Redemption...I couldn't get through. I lost interest in Mexico and haven't played since.

I chose option C: Saint's Row.

 

[DanielBrown]

I enjoyed RDR far more than GTA IV due to RDR having an awesome story, quite a lot of freedom(no one calling me every fifth minute, demanding that I should go bowling) and better "vehicles".
I haven't played GTA IV in a long time now, but from my memory it was nearly impossible to drive around. The handling was awful.