Poll: Is Ice wet?

Recommended Videos

brodie21

New member
Apr 6, 2009
1,598
0
0
Phlakes said:
Wikipedia said:
Wet
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia that anyone can edit

Wet may refer to:
The condition of being liquid or being covered in liquid
So it depends on if it's covered in liquid or not. But by itself, no.
yes, ice is wet. all ice has an extremely thin layer of water (to explain it very simply) on the outside in varying degrees of thickness. the coldest ice has a layer an atom thick. as the ice warms up, this layer gets thicker. this is why hockey players refer to colder ice as 'fast ice' and warm ice as 'slow ice' because the thicker the membrane the slower you can skate across it, the more friction it presents.
 

Assassin Xaero

New member
Jul 23, 2008
5,391
0
0
TimeLord said:
EDIT: Next question: What is "dry ice" and is it wet?
Pretty sure that is a solid (frozen) form of CO2 and ice is a solid form of H2O. As for ice being wet, no. The "wet" part could be the outside layer of it that has started to melt.
 

JLML

New member
Feb 18, 2010
1,452
0
0
ice is as wet as any other solid object. molten rock (lava/magma) is "wet" but that doesn't make rocks wet, right?

Conclusion: Ice is NOT wet.

Also, dry ice will never be wet, since it skips the liquid phase.
 

Brandon237

New member
Mar 10, 2010
2,958
0
0
TimeLord said:
Inspired by the "Is water wet" thread going at the moment

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/18.194049-Poll-The-Poll-to-End-All-Polls-Is-Water-Wet-Your-vote-is-needed

I was drawn to this post:

AshPox said:
dbungus2000 said:
is ice wet?
Now there kiddies, is a better question.
Now, ice is obviously frozen water, being that water makes things wet by being in contact with them. Frozen water is still water, can still melt to make things wet, but the ice block itself is now solid matter, making it an object that can get wet.

I have now sufficiently confused myself

Thoughts?

EDIT: Next question: What is "dry ice" and is it wet?
I said that it is wet as once it comes into contact with any that is not below 0 Celsius, it melts and thus is wet. Just ice in a complete vacuum is dry as those skulls you see in the desert.

Dry ice is not wet as it sublimates and does not have a liquid phase. Dry ice is CO2 that has gotten so cold that it has frozen. Co2 is never a liquid, not until I have my own pressure chamber, that is...
 

AnneSQF

New member
Sep 22, 2009
253
0
0
If its REALLY cold, like your-toes-fall-of-cold when I would say no.
But if its mildly cold, as if it lies in a freezer and it melted a bit it would have water on it and thereby be wet.
By the way: WTF?!?! o_O
 

Fire Daemon

Quoth the Daemon
Dec 18, 2007
3,204
0
0
It depends on the environment, in particular the temperature, for a particular example. If it's warm enough to have melt some of the ice than the ice will be coated in water and hence be wet. That particular ice cube would be wet and that wetness would have come from itself, but this is a water/ice mixture, not ice itself. Iron can be melted and so it can also have a stage in which the core is solid but the outside is liquid, that doesn't mean that iron is wet.

So when no melting is taking place the ice is not wet.

'Dry Ice' is a name for the solid form of Carbon Dioxide, but it should be given another name because ice is frozen water and as stated above, it is also dry (except when melting).

SCIENCE!!!
 

Sakurazaki1023

New member
Feb 15, 2010
681
0
0
TimeLord said:
Inspired by the "Is water wet" thread going at the moment

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/18.194049-Poll-The-Poll-to-End-All-Polls-Is-Water-Wet-Your-vote-is-needed

I was drawn to this post:

AshPox said:
dbungus2000 said:
is ice wet?
Now there kiddies, is a better question.
Now, ice is obviously frozen water, being that water makes things wet by being in contact with them. Frozen water is still water, can still melt to make things wet, but the ice block itself is now solid matter, making it an object that can get wet.

I have now sufficiently confused myself

Thoughts?

EDIT: Next question: What is "dry ice" and is it wet?
If you want to get technical about it, Ice is wet. Since there is no chemical difference between water and ice, they maintain similar chemical properties. Since "wet" is based on the presence of a polar liquid (mercury or oil are liquids at room temperature, but are not considered chemically wet), ice is still chemically composed of water and is thus wet.

Dry ice is not wet because of it's chemical structure. Since dry ice is composed of frozen CO2 gas, it does not contain water or any polar liquid that could distinguish it as wet. If ice is melted it turns into water, however when dry ice "melts" it sublimates directly into a gas.
 

Marter

Elite Member
Legacy
Oct 27, 2009
14,268
19
43
Ice is dry until is begins the melting process, at which point it becomes wet.

Dry ice is solid CO2, and is not wet.
 

Lucifron

New member
Dec 21, 2009
808
0
0
Chemistry 101 much?

No, solidified water isn't wet. Liquid water emanating from it is. An ice cube can be wet because of this. It's really the melting surface layer that is wet, but arguing that an ice cube cannot be wet is nothing but nitpickery.


Addendum: Some areas in Russia, Antarctica and Arctica are classified as deserts, and this is not because they're hot.
 

Arcticflame

New member
Nov 7, 2006
1,060
0
0
No. People are saying that ice can be wet because it forms a coat of water, but this is no longer ice, that is water. No, it is not wet.

Antartica is the driest continent in the world. If ice was wet, this would not be the case.
 

Denamic

New member
Aug 19, 2009
3,803
0
0
Ice is solid.
'Wet' ice is just ice with water on it.
That's the water being wet, not the ice itself.

It's the same with any other meltable substance.
Is iron wet? (it isn't)
Is molten iron wet? (it is)
 
Jun 11, 2008
5,329
0
0
Ice is not wet. Ice is a solid and only appears wet because it melts. It is in fact the water making you wet so no ice is not wet.
 

Kagim

New member
Aug 26, 2009
1,200
0
0
Unless held in a state that water can not form around the outer layer ice is wet.

It's the outer layer of water around the ice that makes it wet.

Otherwise a wet shirt isn't wet. Its a dry shirt because its a solid that just so happens to have water on it which is wet.

Holding ice at room temperature is wet once it begins to melt since the ice, which is now covered in water, is now technically wet.

No different then a t-shirt you soak in water. That's a wet shirt. You don;t hand someone a shirt that's soaking in water telling them its dry unless your a bastard. The shirt is wet because of the water on it.

Therefor the ice cube after it has developed its film of water is now wet.
 

child of lileth

The Norway Italian
Jun 10, 2009
2,248
0
0
I say yes, ice is sort of wet. It's slick, and if it melts even in the slightest, it would be wet. So there's my reasoning.

As for dry ice, I have never seen it in real life, but I heard if you get that wet, it makes smoke, or stream or something.
 

TIMESWORDSMAN

Wishes he had fewer cap letters.
Mar 7, 2008
1,039
0
0
TimeLord said:
Inspired by the "Is water wet" thread going at the moment

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/18.194049-Poll-The-Poll-to-End-All-Polls-Is-Water-Wet-Your-vote-is-needed

I was drawn to this post:

AshPox said:
dbungus2000 said:
is ice wet?
Now there kiddies, is a better question.
Now, ice is obviously frozen water, being that water makes things wet by being in contact with them. Frozen water is still water, can still melt to make things wet, but the ice block itself is now solid matter, making it an object that can get wet.

I have now sufficiently confused myself

Thoughts?

EDIT: Next question: What is "dry ice" and is it wet?
The correct answer is: sometimes.
Ice will be wet (as in a solid object coated in liquid) if it is melted to almost any degree.
However, Ice that is kept in an environment that is as cold or colder than the ice itself will not be wet.

To answer your second question: No, 'Dry ice' or 'Cardice' is frozen Carbon Dioxide and produces no moisture.
 

LornMind

New member
Dec 27, 2008
283
0
0
Assuming ideal conditions, ice is dry.

Given natural conditions, it is wet in any environment above freezing, and will feel wet to any organism that has a sufficiently higher temperature than the ice does.