Technically not.Ciarog said:So there's no exact science behind how much beating a Force block can take? Is there some rough idea on it's limits, or is one to assume the shields can block *anything*? If the latter then I'll concede that the Jedi may very well be indestructible.
Easy.Sinharvest said:okay now i want to see the battle between dr.who and the warp http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immaterium_%28Warhammer_40%2C000%29
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eye_of_harmonyLordOmnit said:Just going based on your description of said time lord, it is possible for him to be ousted or some other term for gotten rid of because it is explicitly stated by you that he isn't the first, and therefore able to be un-done. Not saying a Jedi could do it, but it could be done.
I don't think force heal is going to fix lethal radiation poisoning. It interferes with cell division, so assuming force heal works by regenerating damaged tissue, it's quite possible they wouldn't even be able to attempt it. Also, the proposed battle is one on one, so Battle Meditation is irrelevant.clockpenalty said:ComradeJim270 said:Sure worked nicely for them in Episode III, huh? I'm detecting sarcasm here, yes? Even if that were the case, a droid could do it instead, because there would be no intent to sense, just cold steel, so to speak.clockpenalty said:Wrong. Even movie jedi would sense the Rifleman's evil intent, even if he were across the galaxy. Anime Jedi would force crush him from that distance, too.chenry said:@clockpenalty
One hunting rifle, 700 yards. Jedi dead on the floor before you even hear the shot.
I also humbly submit the nuclear-armed Mobile Infantry of the novel (not the movie, which is parody and is about as true to the book as Spaceballs is to Star Wars) Starship Troopers. Escape the explosion somehow? That's ok, you're already dead from the radiation, it will just take about a week.
In Episode III the Jedi were suffering a blanket blockout of the senses due to Sidious' galaxy-eating power. Nonetheless, remember obi and Ani detecting the mechanical danger to Padme in AOTC? They WILL detect it, even if it is a droid. Its like spiderman's spidey sense- magic power lacking any real biological explanation.
It is canon that you can't just pull a gun on a jedi and kill him. If his reflexes are dull or he doesnt eact in time,you could get him, but ideally the force would prevent such a situation from arising in the first place.
The truth is, the way the force is explained in the movies and novels, it is a plot device that can be used to explain any deus-ex-machina solution a writer can dream of to a Jedi's problems. I suspect the whole idea of Jedi's senses being dulled in the prequels was GL's way of escaping the plot holes that would surface in any story that involved Jedi getting fooled en-masse, aand/or killed by mere stormtroopers.
Minus the overreaching influence of the dark side, the Jedi would be near invincible due to perfect knowledge. Its like playing an FPS aganst a guy using a wallhack and an aimbot- an invisible force that lets him cheat his way to victory. The Jedi were easily fooled by sidious simply because they were overdependent on their senses, so once taken away from them, they stumbled around like a person recently blinded.
Its also worth mentioning that most of the incompetent Jedi were just that- incompetent. Even in the anime, there are many jedi that just get clobbered to death like idiots. The Jedi order *had* grown fat, lazy and weak due to years of prosperity and overconfidence.
Jedi vs mobile infantry? Since we are in novel-land here, I'll have you know that via battle meditation, a Jedi can control an army of millions, spanning an entire planet. This was possible even during the clone wars with underpowered Jedi.
If you want to face movie Jedi, you have to use mobile infantry from the starship troopers movie, and the outcome of that is pretty much cut-and-dry.
EDIT: death from radiation poisoning? Novel Jedi are pretty powerful with the good ol' force heal![]()
Midiwhatzamahuh? Most people who have even a passing interest in Star Wars like to ignore that crap. Also, Han shot first, and last. But the cell division thing is the reason Force Heal would not be likely to work. Stimulating cell division would fail, because the cells would not be able to divide properly. Of course, this would be a non-issue if they don't survive the THERMAL radiation... then they're just ash.ehal256 said:According to Pharsyde's neutral jedi, very very few could take him out.
A couple examples people have said.
1) Aliens (from the Alien series, obviously): 1 on 1 no, powerful jedi masters (Kyle Katarn for example) can use an ability called Force Protection,its pretty much a shield of force energy, to block particles (such as bullets, and blaster bolts), while in combat, so alien acid blood would not kill the jedi. Lightsabers also instantly cauterize wounds that they cause, so no acid spray would be likely to occur.
2)A shotgun: as I explained earlier, force protection would block all incoming particles, if some got through somehow, the jedi could push them back with the force, and block the rest with his/her lightsaber(s).
3)Hunting Rifle: Precognition enough to dodge sniper rifle has been shown in games such as Jedi Knight 2, so no.
4)Anything immune to electricity: a lightsaber is not a jedi master's only weapon, here's a rudimentary list of possible force attacks a master could use, telekinesis based attacks, electric based attacks, pure matter destruction based attacks (Force Destruction, if anyone was wondering), and if powerful enough, direct control of molecules themselves (no jedi has become powerful enough to do any more than create a tiny bit of light afaik).
5)Lethal Radiation Poisoning: I'm not sure about this one, Force Protection could possibly stop it, if not Force Heal could probably repair any damage done, it works at the molecular level with midichlorians, it artificially stimulates cell division wth the energy of the force... if not we have a winnerbut this was about a 1v1
very few characters could take on a jedi 1v1.
Pharsyde's suggestions are all possible though, and Dr. Who (I guess, but it is kinda lame)
Haha. Lightsaber=blade of light, Superman=strengthened by exposure to light. That would be interesting to watch.clockpenalty said:Against Justice league cartoon superheroes, xmen evolution, Goku and Naruto, use the animated versions from Clone wars. (Goku wins, Naruto Loses, JLU heroes mostly lose except those with extreme abilities- supes, wonderwoman)