Given the level of customization in LEGO games, the character is never really the same. Sure, sometimes they
make you play as Luke Skywalker, but a lot of the time you can customize and play as that. Because of this, you can't have a single game-plot with already familiarized characters. That would mean no customization, and that would stop people (Or me, at least) from even caring that it's LEGO. That's why you need a game like Drawn to Life, one where it's not taking the plot from a movie or previous other game and there's no set character; only one you make. You need a whole new plot, themed solely around LEGO people, customization of your surroundings, and interaction with new enemies, not old ones from other games.
And what about a LEGO World of Warcraft? You can, I don't know, earn money by doing quests to buy bricks so you can build a... Mount? That has to be a good idea, right? Wouldn't that be awesome? Plus, there'd be other players.
Oh... Er... I've been beaten to the punch. Ladies and gentlemen; LEGO UNIVERSE.
It's got ninja themes, pirates, spaceships, and you can make
any creation you want. Why is this not up there on the poll?