Poll: Need help picking what to purchase

[jackpackage200]

Two days ago was my birthday and i got a $40 gift card to best buy from my dad . I was looking online and i saw a couple things that caught my eye. i could get red dead redemption or i could get both bioshock and saints row 2 which i heard are both fantastic games. Which should i pick?

Any other suggestions are welcome.

EDIT: I should post what i already have

Call of Duty Black Ops
Batman Arkham Asylum
Assassins Creed Brotherhood
La Noire
Portal 2
Mortal Kombat
Uncharted 2
Alice Madness Returns
Fallout New Vegas
Crysis 2
God of War Collection
God of War 3
Prince of Persia Trilogy
Just Cause 2

 

[OrenjiJusu]

i'd personally say bioshock ans SR2, Cause Bioshock is a very fun heavily story driven game, and SR2 is a very fun insane sandbox game

 

[Wrath 228]

That's like choosing between shooting yourself in the head with a shotgun and a slightly bigger shotgun. In the end though, I had to go with SR2 and Bioshock.

 

[jackpackage200]

What about both bioshock games? is two just as "amazing" as one?