Poll: Panorama: Game Addictions Documentary

Recommended Videos

The Funslinger

Corporate Splooge
Sep 12, 2010
6,145
0
0
On the BBC, quite recently, there was a documentary called Panorama. Basically, it covers the possibly addictive nature of games and how they are supposedly ruining people's lives. Now hardly a day goes by on the Escapist without several member's heads exploding from rage at some discrimination against video games by people who have never played them.

Click below for my take on it. (it goes on for a bit. Also, I know there was a thread about the leaked concept of the documentary, it's linked below.)

Any British Escapist members will probably know what I'm talking about. I know there was a thread about the leaked concept of this documentary: [link]http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/105867-BBC-Documentary-to-Investigate-Videogame-Addiction[/link] but now it's actually come to light, it deserves some analysis by Escapist as a whole. Anyone in the UK who missed it can watch it for the next few days on BBC iplayer, anyone else can probably find some bits floating around on youtube, or something. I don't know if it'll be on BBC America.

As described by the thread linked above, it was surprisingly even handed. The documentary described addiction tactics used in games, namely the offering of rewards at frequent intervals, though not too often as to become repetitive.

It is based off of an experiment that rats can learn to press a button for food, but if the button only disperses food on some random presses, but not others, the rat will push the button obsessively. This can be compared to loot drops on games such as World of Warcraft, and Fallout.

One man, who was so addicted to World of Warcraft that he almost completely severed ties with family said, "I wouldn't wish this game on anyone. It's a disease." He was attempting to wean himself off the game, and was revisited later in the show. He had relapsed, and made excuses as to why he had returned to the game. He was playing the game whilst being interviewed, and snubbed the show's interviewer and narrator, because of events in game.

The documentary does admit, however, that the vast majority of people do not get so easily addicted to gaming. In Korea, for example, which has the most advanced Broadband system in the world, and has around 50% of people with broadband playing online games, only 2% of people were "addicted." Granted, that is still a vast amount of people, but it proves it's far from universal.

The documentary touches upon recent events that found their way into media, such as parents neglecting their child because they were protecting a virtual child from harm. Over all, though, it's much fairer to gaming than the other anti-gaming campaigns in recent times.
 

Anarchemitis

New member
Dec 23, 2007
9,100
0
0
While an aspect of modern 'Big Box' game developers is to make a game which tries to have the playe continue to patron their game and services, you would have a very different documentary if they focused on different aspects that are in games and their craft, such as Ludology (the creation and interweavement of story and narrative within the game), gameplay, design theory, mechanics, social and player based subcultures found within games, Game economics and technological innovations, to name a few.
 

the Dept of Science

New member
Nov 9, 2009
1,007
0
0
I've not watched the program, but it sounds like its talking about the Skinner Box effect that certain games have. Games like WoW and Farmville exploit this effect for all that its worth, because it is in their interest to get you addicted to it. On the other hand, games which you pay for once, which rely on things like narrative have no more of an addicting effect than a good book. I've played through Bioshock and Psychonauts a couple of times each, but I didn't consider it any different from watching a favourite movie again.
From the sounds of it though, this is one of those "all tarred with the same brush" problems. Certain games are potentially addictive, however, things like this lead people to believe that they are all addictive.
 

Fridge

New member
Jun 25, 2009
260
0
0
I'm actually in the process of watching this show now, I've taken a break from it though because its making me really really angry.

A case in point I just watched a section where a young lad was playing WoW and refused to go to school because he didn't want to miss events in the game. When the parents cut off his net connection he flew into a violent rage, kicking doors, punching walls etc. They blamed it on the game and it being addictive and 'dangerous'. I personally say that what he had there was a tantrum, I used to have them when I was young (I'm talking 8 - 10 years old though).
There is also another lad earlier in the show who plays CoD for hours at a time, sometimes going 12 hours. Yep... I've done that too, I call it time distortion but basically its getting engrossed and losing track of time. He dropped out of uni and has no money, no job and is apparently losing friends. That isn't addiction its being LAZY, I was unemployed for 2 years and used a hell of a lot of time to play games (yes 12 hours or more in a day) but that never interfered with my social and love life and it now doesn't interfere with my working life either.

So heres a hint to those guys. Put down the controller / mouse and go for a damn walk, or go paint balling, rock climbing, see mates, learn to breathe fire I don't care. Just stop playing its not that hard.

Sorry about that rant but this sort of scaremongering gets me very angry.