Poll: Pie or Cake?

[Jamash]

I like carrot cake, I also like apple & cheddar pie, any kind of meat pie & can cook a mean shepherds/cottage pie.

As a general rule I'd have pie for dinner & cake for pudding.

 

[UltraBlumpkin]

Pie is winning by 1! =D

 

[Dudemeister]

Chocolate cake

 

[Hazufrazen]

Pie for the win cuz princess peach keeps giving up her... cake, there is no cake for it is a lie, and pies are much better to throw in faces. pie for the win. PIES FOREVER!!!!!!

 

[badgersprite]

Cheesecake is the best fucking thing ever. No question. If I could, I would construct a pagan idol out of cheesecakes and worship it as my God. I would sacrifice my firstborn on the altar of cheesecake if it so decreed me to.

 

[Liam1390]

Good question.

If I have a choice of what to make for someone, I'll make a pie, it's easier for me to make and everyone always likes the fact that I make an all butter crust.

I don't often make cakes because I'm horrible at piping out icing.

For eating, it depends on where I'm eating, and the choices that I have. If I know the person uses shortening for the crust, I'm going with cake. If there's a cake that I have a weakness for(mocha, black forest) available with a good quality frosting, then I'm going to be digging into the cake.

 

[Judgement101]

I don't really like pie, so hand me a big slice of lie.

Seriously? A Portal reference...oh well, I like cake.

 

[NeedAUserName]

It amazes me when people dig up threads from two years ago. I mean it must have taken a fair bit of effort to do it...

 

[likalaruku]

I don't really like the taste of "sweet," but a sugar-free pie is just as good as a frostingless cake.

 

[brtshstel]

Both are good, but I love pie. I have worked in food service before, so I know a thing or two about making good pie crust. You can make a pie out of anything, but if the crust isn't good, then the whole pie isn't good.

 

[UberNoodle]

Cake, because for me, pies are pastry pockets with hot mince beef and gravy inside. Where I'm from, that's what's synonymous with the word "pie". Wouldn't have it any other way. Apple and cherry, etc? I shudder at the thought.

 

[Sn1P3r M98]

Pie. The frosting on cake makes me nauseous.

 

[Skorpyo]

Can you make a chicken-pot-cake? No. Can you make a bacon cake? No.

Therefore, pie.

 

[FalloutJack]

Pike! (Pie + Cake)

 

[Nouw]

Here's a heads-up: The Escapist doesn't really like VS threads here. PM a moderator (wilsoncrazybed, nilcypher) to lock it for you.

Although cake wins any day.

No I believe VS threads aren't allowed if it's asking which is better.

"Which is better, cake or pie?"
"Which do you prefer, cake or pie?"
See?

Anyway, since each countries definition of pie and cake is different I will simply say that I like pies better only because the only type of cake I like is cheesecake and as godly as that is, not enough to beat this beauty.

Refer to my avatar also.

Pike! (Pie + Cake)

Spoiler: Pike?

or

 

[Lizmichi]

PIE!! Pie is soo much better then cake but I do like cake as well.