Poll: Screen One: Paul

Recommended Videos

jackanderson

New member
Sep 7, 2008
703
0
0
Film: Paul
Director: Greg Mottola
Written By: Simon Pegg, Nick Frost
Distributor: Universal Pictures
Run Time: 1 hour 41 minutes
Starring: Simon Pegg, Nick Frost, Kristen Wigg, Jason Bateman, Seth Rogan

Paul is a sci-fi comedy written by and starring Simon Pegg and Nick Frost as two friends on a tour of the US when they stumble across a smoking, drug taking, swearing, lewd and rude alien voiced by Seth Rogan. He's attempting to get back to his home world whilst being chased by an FBI agent played by Jason Bateman whose superior is Sigourney Weaver. Along the way they run into a mad, one eyed Christian played by Kristin Wigg who joins the trio and send up almost every single sci-fi cliché and popular sci-fi film in the book.

On paper then, Paul should be perfect. A comedy on the level of Shaun Of The Dead or Hot Fuzz (the previous two films that the pair starred in which were also co-written and directed by Edgar Wright, who is MIA for this one). In practice, there is good and bad news. The bad news is that it is most certainly no Shaun Of The Dead or Hot Fuzz. There are far too many issues with the film for it to be as good as those. But the good news is that Paul is a very funny comedy, possibly the funniest I've watched since Scott Pilgrim (although, please note, this is nowhere near as funny as that masterwork).

Down on the acting front, it's mostly great. Pegg and Frost are basically playing the same lovable nerdy best friends that they always do, but they are still great in those roles and it does frequently look like they're having lots of fun. Kristen Wigg continues to prove why she is the fastest rising star in comedy as, after her absolutely brilliant role in the underrated MacGruber, she displays impeccable comic timing and gets quite a lot of the best lines. Whilst Seth Rogan is superb as Paul, bringing a nice sarcastic edge to the alien that reminded me why I liked him so much in Knocked Up.

It's not all great news when it comes to the stars, though. There's nothing wrong with the actual acting, everybody gives it their all and everybody gets at least a funny line, it's instead some of the casting. There is some colossal wastage of talent going on in this movie. Prime example: Jason Bateman. The man, if any of you have seen Arrested Development can attest to, is absolutely freakin' hilarious. Unfortunately, his role is that of a tough, no-nonsense Jack Bauer-type FBI agent and he is very rarely given a chance to be funny, with the film expecting you to buy him as a tough, no-nonsense Jack Bauer-type which I just can?t do.

Also wasted: Sigourney Weaver who, whilst funny when she appears, gets bugger all to do. And whilst the cameos from Jane Lynch and Jeffery Tambor are great, that's all they are and it really made me wish those two were in more movies. So whilst everybody is great in Paul, and most are really funny, some very poor (and some inexcusable) wastage of talent is evident here. At least Paul himself looks great with the CGI work doing a fantastic job of making him look convincing and not too out of place in the world of the movie.

But Paul is primarily a comedy, so all of the great performances and CG is for nought if the film isn't the least bit funny. Well I'm happy to report that the film is mostly very funny. It's certainly nowhere near as subtle as the other genre send-ups like Shaun... and Hot Fuzz, with the references mostly being bludgeoned into your face ("Get away from her you *****"? Wonder where I've heard that one before?) and the film frequently going for swearword gags. However, I'd be lying if I told you that I wasn't spending the majority of the run time in hysterics. You see; Paul swings hard a lot so when it misses, it's noticeable. But when it hits, and it does so frequently, it hits it out of the ball park. One particularly funny moment involves a recreation of the famous Gorn fight from Star Trek. Plus, there's some very creative swearing that actually made me laugh loads.

The script does feature a bit of flab, though. The film starts up a debate about Creationism vs. Evolution that it then abandons after about two minutes, and before that treats it about as well as a McDonalds cattle raising farm. It feels really out of place and it's not really that necessary. Also, the romantic sub plot between Pegg and Wigg is really awkward and pointless. Unless that's meant to be the joke, in which case, well played.

So yeah; there's some colossal misuse of stellar actors, some unnecessary plot lines and it's about as subtle as a sledgehammer to the skull, but, dammit, Paul is damn funny! When you stop comparing Paul to Shaun... and Hot Fuzz, it stands much better. It's a very funny movie with great comedic talent turning in great performances with a great script to back them up along with some of the most creative swearing I've heard since In The Loop (yes, that really is a selling point). If you've seen Pegg & Frost's previous comedies, temper your expectations heading in and you'll find it very enjoyable. Otherwise, get yourself down to the cinema and see Paul.

If I was a hack reviewer looking to end on a pun, I'd say that Paul is "a hilarious comedy that's out of this world". But I'm not. So I'm just simply going to recommend you go and see Paul ASAP.

4 out of 5.
 

Super Six One

New member
Apr 23, 2009
474
0
0
jackanderson said:
^Scott Pilgrim (although, please note, this is nowhere near as funny as that masterwork).

1.Jason Bateman.
2.Sigourney Weaver
3the romantic sub plot between Pegg and Wigg is really awkward and pointless.
^Wow, i found Scott Pilgrim one of the worse films i've seen in a long time

1. I though he fit his character fairly well, him and the other two FBI guys had some funny moments. The bit wher he checks that small puddle of pee?
2. She was only supposed to be a a cameo
3. Yea the gay sub-plot has been in all of their films, even in Spaced(their tv series, if you haven't seen it give it a watch, its good)


But i totally agree, good film, not their top due to the fact that Shawn of the Dead and Hot Fuzz are awsome, 4 out of 5 from me too.


Oh and you might be happy to hear this is not the third "Blood and Ice-cream" film, so when Edgar Wright(?) is back in the directors chair we should be getting another Pegg aand Frost film.
 

tomtom94

aka "Who?"
May 11, 2009
3,370
0
0
Saw this Friday night, loved it...just really hoping Simon Pegg stops being such an in-demand actor (two Star Trek sequels, Tintin, Mission Impossible IV...) so we can get the third Blood and Ice Cream film.

Good review too, though you could stand to expand your points a little more. It feels a bit disjointed when you're skipping to a new paragraph every five lines.


[small]Also Scott Pilgrim is awesome.[/small]
 

CrashBang

New member
Jun 15, 2009
2,602
0
0
Loved every single minute. I love Pegg and Frost. I love Rogen even more. I thoroughly enjoyed the mix of comedy styles and all of the great sci-fi references ("Boomer, no, it's forbidden!" - Brilliant)
I'll be getting it as soon as it comes out on blu-ray
 

Flamezdudes

New member
Aug 27, 2009
3,695
0
0
It was a pretty funny film, close to being as good as Shaun of the Dead. But I loved it!
 

jackanderson

New member
Sep 7, 2008
703
0
0
Christ, I forgot I posted my review here. Anyways, responses!
Super Six One said:
jackanderson said:
^Scott Pilgrim (although, please note, this is nowhere near as funny as that masterwork).

1.Jason Bateman.
2.Sigourney Weaver
3the romantic sub plot between Pegg and Wigg is really awkward and pointless.
^Wow, i found Scott Pilgrim one of the worse films i've seen in a long time

1. I though he fit his character fairly well, him and the other two FBI guys had some funny moments. The bit wher he checks that small puddle of pee?
2. She was only supposed to be a a cameo
3. Yea the gay sub-plot has been in all of their films, even in Spaced(their tv series, if you haven't seen it give it a watch, its good)


But i totally agree, good film, not their top due to the fact that Shawn of the Dead and Hot Fuzz are awsome, 4 out of 5 from me too.


Oh and you might be happy to hear this is not the third "Blood and Ice-cream" film, so when Edgar Wright(?) is back in the directors chair we should be getting another Pegg aand Frost film.
If you don't like Scott Pilgrim, fair enough. I'm fine with it. Honestly. If you saw The Expendables and preferred that, I'm ok with that too.

Obvious digs aside, I'm mostly sad about Jason Bateman due to the fact that FX are re-running Arrested Development and it's reminded me just how damn funny he is. It makes me wish he did more comedy roles in films. Though he was fantastic with his material.

If Sigourney Weaver was supposed to be a cameo, how come her name was on the poster? Is this an Expendables thing where cameos are added to get bigger draws?

I'm fine with the gay subplot, I think it's more the complete shoe-horning of the Kristen Wigg/Simon Pegg romance. I didn't think it fit well, personally.

I'm dying for the upcoming third in the Blood & Ice Cream Trilogy! Hopefully after everyone involved is finished with Tin Tin (no, really. Pegg, Frost and Wright are involved in the new Tin Tin movie) they can get it out pronto!

Thanks for the comment!
tomtom94 said:
Saw this Friday night, loved it...just really hoping Simon Pegg stops being such an in-demand actor (two Star Trek sequels, Tintin, Mission Impossible IV...) so we can get the third Blood and Ice Cream film.

Good review too, though you could stand to expand your points a little more. It feels a bit disjointed when you're skipping to a new paragraph every five lines.


[small]Also Scott Pilgrim is awesome.[/small]
As said above, I approve of the demand for the third Blood And Ice Cream film!

Thanks for the feedback. I used to get complaints that my reviews were too long and too detailed so I've attempted to make them more concise to appeal to them. I'll see if I can expand for the next one. Again, thanks!

[small]P.S. Scott Pilgrim most certainly is awesome![/small]
 

The Wykydtron

"Emotions are very important!"
Sep 23, 2010
5,457
0
0
This film gave me my new favourite one liner

Crazy Hillbilly Mega Christian: I'm on a mission from God!
FBI guy: Tell him you failed *boom*

Pretty good review although i liked the Creationism v Evolutionism plotline probably because i like watching Mega Christians quote the Bible instead of coming up with their own arguements.

Also did noone get the Destroy All Humans reference towards the end? The alien saucer folds up its legs just like in the game! Well played Paul... Well played