Poll: Should they make a Punk Band/Hardcore Hero?

[SonicKoala]

I love punk rock, but a whole game revolving around the genre would be excessive. So no, best not to venture into that realm. Also, hate to do this, but you suggested "hardcore" bands like Rise Against and Billy Talent..... if you're referring to the sub-genre of punk known as "hardcore", those bands are in no way part of that genre. Dead Kennedys, Black Flag and Husker Du are 3 examples of bands that actually played "hardcore" punk. Sorry, someone had to be the music elitist and point that out.

 

[CoziestPigeon]

They need a music game with independent bands, or ones that are less known. Enter Shikari, August Burns Red, Skylit Drive, Attack Attack!, Chiodos......the list goes on and on.

LOLLLLLLLL
You better be kidding about the Attack Attack thing.
Or any band on that list, for that matter.

That's their bassist. Or any other member of the band, since they all look like the same person.
It's hilarious how the bassist pretends he/she can play.

Hey genius, that's a guitar he's playing.

Hot damn! That changes the whole idea of this argument! Its no longer about the quality of a guitarist/bassist in a band, no.. Now it's about how well you can tell which instrument is which! Waaaay more important apparently. I mean what kind of life would we live if every little detail wasn't fondled and shaken until it stands, limping, for all the world to see?

If you don't even know what an instrument looks like, how on Earth can you form a valid opinion of music? Besides, you brought the picture in as an argument for why the music sucks. Basically, you tried to use something against it, but you didn't even understand what you were using. You use the picture to show he's a terrible musician, which made no sense in the first place, and you were wrong about what instrument he plays. Your argument is entirely invalid.

 

[CoziestPigeon]

Hey genius, that's a guitar he's playing.

That my friend, is an argument for another thread. They suck and do not deserve to be in anything was my point.
And i can't tell if it's a bass or guitar, I've looked at the fret distances. But who cares? Then their guitarist is bad at faking he can play.

Who cares about fret differences? The strings are way the fuck to thin, and, well, there are 6 of them.

Also, every single musician since the beginning of music videos fakes playing in a video. You think they record that live? Fuck no! The song with the video is already pre-mastered, you can't just mix that shit on the fly. Of course he's faking it in a music video, that's what you do.

 

[Jekken6]

just fucking license Stairway To Heavem, already!

 

[Daedalus1942]

I love punk rock, especially hardcore. I also like and play Rock Band and Guitar Hero, so I thought it would be awesome to make a Punk version of Rock Band or Guitar Hero, with classics like The Ramones, Social Distortion, The Clash, hardcore like Rise Against and Billy Talent, and pop-punk would be cool too like Sum 41 and The Offspring.
Thoughts?

No!
Let the flood of piss-poor mediocre musical titles with crappy easily destroyable plastic peripherals evaporate away... Please!

 

[GoldenCondor]

Hey genius, that's a guitar he's playing.

That my friend, is an argument for another thread. They suck and do not deserve to be in anything was my point.
And i can't tell if it's a bass or guitar, I've looked at the fret distances. But who cares? Then their guitarist is bad at faking he can play.

Who cares about fret differences? The strings are way the fuck to thin, and, well, there are 6 of them.

Also, every single musician since the beginning of music videos fakes playing in a video. You think they record that live? Fuck no! The song with the video is already pre-mastered, you can't just mix that shit on the fly. Of course he's faking it in a music video, that's what you do.

Dude, it looks TOO fake. I meant he/she can at least give the idea that they know how to play. I will never understand hardcore music, i guess, and i never plan on it. Any other musical genre would at least move their damn fingers.

I can't see the 6 strings on my computer moniter, in fact, I see one.

 

[CoziestPigeon]

They need a music game with independent bands, or ones that are less known. Enter Shikari, August Burns Red, Skylit Drive, Attack Attack!, Chiodos......the list goes on and on.

LOLLLLLLLL
You better be kidding about the Attack Attack thing.
Or any band on that list, for that matter.

That's their bassist. Or any other member of the band, since they all look like the same person.
It's hilarious how the bassist pretends he/she can play.

No.....I wasn't. Yeah they look like retards in that video, but that doesn't mean their music is bad. They actually have some good stuff. And you think the other bands I listed are bad? ABR is amazing for one.
PS: that's a guitar he's playing but good try I guess.

I shouldn't have been a dick with the way i answered it, but i really dislike Attack Attack! and i don't like any of the other bands on there. They are all quite well known, too. Actually, never heard of "Enter Shikari".

You can see the way more than 4 pegs at the head. Bass guitars just don't look like that. But have you seen the whole video? For all we know they are doing that as a joke. Lots of bands like to joke around and have fun in music videos.

 

[GoldenCondor]

They need a music game with independent bands, or ones that are less known. Enter Shikari, August Burns Red, Skylit Drive, Attack Attack!, Chiodos......the list goes on and on.

LOLLLLLLLL
You better be kidding about the Attack Attack thing.
Or any band on that list, for that matter.

That's their bassist. Or any other member of the band, since they all look like the same person.
It's hilarious how the bassist pretends he/she can play.

No.....I wasn't. Yeah they look like retards in that video, but that doesn't mean their music is bad. They actually have some good stuff. And you think the other bands I listed are bad? ABR is amazing for one.
PS: that's a guitar he's playing but good try I guess.

I shouldn't have been a dick with the way i answered it, but i really dislike Attack Attack! and i don't like any of the other bands on there. They are all quite well known, too. Actually, never heard of "Enter Shikari".

You can see the way more than 4 pegs at the head. Bass guitars just don't look like that. But have you seen the whole video? For all we know they are doing that as a joke. Lots of bands like to joke around and have fun in music videos.

They were trying during that music video. They made another one for the same song, except on a bridge and just as dumb ridiculous.

 

[Rooster893]

Blink 182 and Dead Kennedys for Punk rock, and Mastodon and Dethklok for hardcore.

 

[CoziestPigeon]

They need a music game with independent bands, or ones that are less known. Enter Shikari, August Burns Red, Skylit Drive, Attack Attack!, Chiodos......the list goes on and on.

LOLLLLLLLL
You better be kidding about the Attack Attack thing.
Or any band on that list, for that matter.

That's their bassist. Or any other member of the band, since they all look like the same person.
It's hilarious how the bassist pretends he/she can play.

No.....I wasn't. Yeah they look like retards in that video, but that doesn't mean their music is bad. They actually have some good stuff. And you think the other bands I listed are bad? ABR is amazing for one.
PS: that's a guitar he's playing but good try I guess.

I shouldn't have been a dick with the way i answered it, but i really dislike Attack Attack! and i don't like any of the other bands on there. They are all quite well known, too. Actually, never heard of "Enter Shikari".

You can see the way more than 4 pegs at the head. Bass guitars just don't look like that. But have you seen the whole video? For all we know they are doing that as a joke. Lots of bands like to joke around and have fun in music videos.

They were trying during that music video. They made another one for the same song, except on a bridge and just as dumb ridiculous.

On the other hand, these guys don't exactly play hard music, that weak strumming one string may actually be how that song goes.

 

[GoldenCondor]

On the other hand, these guys don't exactly play hard music, that weak strumming one string may actually be how that song goes.

You're a fan, you should recognize the song.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQVpITyOdc8

Oh my god I could not stop laughing when I watched that right now. It's supposed to sound so serious, but they do these stupid, stupid synced dancing moves and the vocalist dances on one leg at a time... Disgraceful.

 

[CoziestPigeon]

On the other hand, these guys don't exactly play hard music, that weak strumming one string may actually be how that song goes.

You're a fan, you should recognize the song.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQVpITyOdc8

Oh my god I could not stop laughing when I watched that right now. It's supposed to sound so serious, but they do these stupid, stupid synced dancing moves and the vocalist dances on one leg at a time... Disgraceful.

Definitely not a fan, just making assumption.

 

[leighjet]

some different bands like cradle of filth and parkway drive ..
they should just expand genres a bit more

 

[GoldenCondor]

On the other hand, these guys don't exactly play hard music, that weak strumming one string may actually be how that song goes.

You're a fan, you should recognize the song.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQVpITyOdc8

Oh my god I could not stop laughing when I watched that right now. It's supposed to sound so serious, but they do these stupid, stupid synced dancing moves and the vocalist dances on one leg at a time... Disgraceful.

Definitely not a fan, just making assumption.

Oh
Sorry, mistaked you for OP of this argument, McGee.