Poll: Stealth Action

[Stringytank]

So this popped into my head yesterday and I thought I'd put it here.
Who do you think is better/stealthier/ would win in a fight, Snake from the Metal Gear Solid series, or Sam Fisher from the Splinter Cell series?
Also give a reason why.

 

[Vlane]

Sam Fisher. I love the MGS games but Snake is not as stealthy as Fisher.

 

[Bored Tomatoe]

Sam is much stealthier and a total badass. Not to say snake isn't, but I just like Sam's dark humor in the first 3 games.

 

[Galletea]

Snake doesn't have to be stealthy, that's not a requirement. He's as stealthy as you like.
He's more attractive and has a better voice.
But vs threads aren't very cool. Just thought I'd let you know. They tend to die pretty quick.

 

[Stringytank]

Snake doesn't have to be stealthy, that's not a requirement. He's as stealthy as you like.
He's more attractive and has a better voice.
But vs threads aren't very cool. Just thought I'd let you know. They tend to die pretty quick.

Yeah I was afraid of that and a flame war about MGS4 and the PS3.

 

[Seydaman]

sam ftw

 

[Eagle Est1986]

Sam would probably win on Stealth but Snake would win in every other way, he even gets more women than lonely old Sam.

 

[rossatdi]

Who do you think is better/stealthier/ would win in a fight, Snake from the Metal Gear Solid series, or Sam Fisher from the Splinter Cell series?

Garrett from Thief.

 

[Theo Samaritan]

You know I came into this thread hoping for a meaningful discussion on action in stealth games.

Instead I get a vs thread that has been repeated too many times to count =/

 

[GloatingSwine]

Who do you think is better/stealthier/ would win in a fight, Snake from the Metal Gear Solid series, or Sam Fisher from the Splinter Cell series?

Garrett from Thief.

Sam Fisher is basically Garrett with guns. And a bit more sarcasm. And Michael Ironside.

 

[rossatdi]

Who do you think is better/stealthier/ would win in a fight, Snake from the Metal Gear Solid series, or Sam Fisher from the Splinter Cell series?

Garrett from Thief.

Sam Fisher is basically Garrett with guns. And a bit more sarcasm. And Michael Ironside.

But does Fisher have fire/water/light arrows? Silent and useful.

 

[Steve Dark]

Stealth Action? Bit of an oxymoron dontcha think? Surely if you're any good at being stealthy there won't be any action?

 

[Xojins]

Sam Fisher is definitely better. He actually has to rely on shadows and other things around him to sneak around, whereas Snake can basically turn invisible whenever he wants. Also, Sam Fisher has an array of very ineffective guns (unless you're using the other attachments), which places a stronger emphasis on the stealth aspect of the game. Snake, on the other hand, can carry one of every gun known to man, which defeats the purpose of sneaking around, in my opinion.

 

[Eldritch Warlord]

Having only played the first Metal Gear Solid (which I didn't like because it was old and clunky) I don't think I'm in position to judge.

But screw honesty, Sam Fisher rules!

 

[Frapple]

Not Snake.

So... this "Sam Fisher" character gets my vote.

No Garrett? When were you people born?