I tend to prefer when a woman wears little or no makeup. I can usually tell. Maybe if the makeup is particularly good I wouldn't notice it but naked skin has a look of its own. Sometimes extravagant makeup may look good. A woman I met a while back would often draw designs around her eyes with makeup and glitter. Once she had a butterfly wing on the side of each eye. It was cute. Of course I was younger then, I might not go for that so much any more.
Edit: The worst is fake nails. I hate them. Particularly french tips. They are ugly as sin.
Edit: The worst is fake nails. I hate them. Particularly french tips. They are ugly as sin.