Eh, I played it but it wasn't bad. There are cirtainly worse games.
The main problem I had with it was the controls. I've played PC RTSs and the "click and drag" functions are dearly missed. Also holding shift to deselect preselected units without deselecting all of them. And assigning teams. Nitpicks, I know, but annoying nitpicks when you use them all the fucking time on other games...
Smaller issues I had were with buildings and unit caps. You can only build bases in cirtain areas (unlike other RTS I have played, with the excpetion of Celtic Kings: Rage of War [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celtic_Kings:_Rage_of_War], but that's more of a "Civilization in real time" game than an RTS.). This means you can only build turrets next to you bases, not at the critical choke points. So you build some tanks instead, but soon run out of people because of the unit cap (which most RTSs don't have, or its so fucking high, you will never hit it unless you build 50000000 units). Take Red Alert [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Alert] (1 and 2, I don't have 3...) for example. There is a unit cap. It's just hidden and has to do with the game not being able to address a million billion units because of memory issues. I actually hit the RE2 unit cap once because I was building hundreds of GIs and deploying their heavy machine guns all around the enemy's base. If he tried to leave, death ensued. Or Supreme Commander 2 [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supreme_Commander_2]. There normally is a 500 unit and building cap (which you hit easily once you get good at it, also done for memory reasons). You can also easily edit the game xmls to raise it to, say, 5000. The AI can't handle that many units (probably another reason for the cap, he just piles anything over 500 in his base), but you can. It tends to fuck up saving and loading, but it sure is fun.
My point is I didn't like the controls or the unit cap.
I do like the squads of soldiers, the upgrades, and the units themselves. And you can make Spartans. Win.
Overall, OK; fun, but annoying at times. Would have been better on the PC because then I could mod everything bad about it out.
On that note, does anybody know of an Xbox 360 emulator (for the PC)? Because it would be cool to do what I just said.