I dont really want to turn this into a nature vs nurture thread but i'll just say that having done this for both biology and psychology at university, and speaking from a personal level, i'd have to disagree, nurture is more important to me (tbh i think its more a mixture but i definatly feel experiance is more important than genes)MasterMuffinMan said:Don't underestimate the connection made by all members of the family to their own baby. Not to mention the fact that sharing a genetic bond makes differences that you would never notice otherwise. I am the only natural child of my parents' 4 children, and despite my siblings having the same upbringing as me, they are completely different people to me and my parents. They exhibit behaviour and mannerisms that none of us have, but that their birth families (who they have minimal contact with) do.Ilikemilkshake said:Im not a girl, so i'd probably have less of a biological connection to any potential babies, So that doesnt really bother me.Shiny Koi said:Yeah... come to think of it... This would eliminate most of the concerns I cited with having kids, personally. And it would give a kid a second chance at life.Ilikemilkshake said:I'll probably adopt (assuming my partner was okay with that)
i just dont really fancy the baby stage. Plus giving a kid a new home seems like a nicer thing to do.
The only thing is, that whole baby stage you mention is where a lot of the essential bonds are formed. A kid you adopt can be just as gracious and loved by you as any child you raised yourself, but I don't know if that level of bondedness would ever be present.
But obviously its something that would be taken into consideration for the significant other.
Experience speaking here: nature beats nurture every time. I'm not saying that adoption is a bad thing - not at all, it's a huge thing to be able to do - but think incredibly carefully before doing so. Children who are in a position to be adopted are probably from a difficult background (the proportion of cases of orphans who have no family to take them in is very low), so there will most likely be attachment issues.
tl;dr - Adoption ain't all like Annie, it's just that no-one tells the stories of what it's like when it goes wrong.
I've had alot of parenting issues, they broke up shortly after my brother was born, before they were married, and i spent years moving from place to place, switching between which parents i lived with before my dad won custody and we moved country.
I can with 100% certainty say personality wise i am how i am because of my experiances growing up. Now i know that wont be true for alot of people, im just saying theres no definate answer.
As for bonding with a child who is adopted, i'd almost say i would be able to bond more with a child who had a rough upbringing because i could more easily see them as being similar to myself, than if i had an arbitrary connection of blood to my own child.
hopefully i havent come across as heartless as i think i have but hey thats just me.