People won't praise a game for how optimized an engine is and how beautiful and smooth it looks on Medium graphic setting (more beautiful AND smoother than most other games on their Highest, e.g. COD4, Bioshock around the same time), IF it gives them a "Highest" option that they can't run.
So what should Crytek have done to make people happy? Hiding graphic options above medium, and profit.
So what should Crytek have done to make people happy? Hiding graphic options above medium, and profit.