Well this is going to be mildly irritating now. It sucking would just add to the noise that is complaining about AAA so it'd have an irrelevant effect, it being good means we got another possible internet darling on our hands.
Anyway good review, but I'll have to see more stuff around the net before I can be convinced. If I hear a horror game is good I always have to question its merits due to them usually having all those elements used by all that indie garbage.