Right, what to get rid of?

[Flamezdudes]

Basically, i'm pretty low on cash and REALLY want to buy Bad Company 2 or Dragon Age: Awakening so i wanna know what i should trade in, just one since i have ton's of family members coming over this month and they usually give me some cash too.

Mass Effect 1
Mass Effect 2
Batman: AA
Assassin's Creed
Prototype
Bioshock 1
The Orange Box

 

[delet]

Mass Effect. Why would you play the first now that you have the second?

Or Assassin's Creed, as it's not much fun after you beat it once.

 

[SnootyEnglishman]

Don't trade any of them in unless you have a PC then you can trade in Orange Box.

 

[jpakaferrari]

Well I don't know how much you expect to get but the value of all of these games as completely different. Assassin's Creed is gonna break a lot less than say Batman because of the length of time its been on the market and it has a sequel. So you might want to look online at what price Game Stop or where ever is selling each one for and then figure they will give you at best 15-20% of that. Unfortunately thats how business works.

 

[asdasdasdasda]

AC1 is pretty crap on second (or more) playthrough. I guess I'd pick that one.

 

[Ironic Pirate]

Assassin's creed, like Aby said it's not a very replayable game.

 

[the_pleasure_is_mine]

I'd say prototype, assassins creed and batman. Because they have little replayability.

 

[reg42]

Prototype, Bioshock, Ass Creed... Yeah. One or more of those.

 

[Johnnyallstar]

See if you can get some cash by doing some chores, or doing some work for somebody. A little hard work pays off.

I say this because I got to take half a day off, with a full day's pay because I'm a hard working mofo

 

[sinsfire]

prototype, bioshock, assassins creed. do not get rid of the mass effect games. not sure about anyone else but after i imported one character to me2, i wanted to start me1 over to try different thing sand see how they would import into me2. i imagine i will do the same when me3 comes out.

besides me1 probably isn't worth much these days

 

[Jeronus]

Mass effect 1 because I doubt you will want to go all the way to the beginning of ME1 to see how it translates to ME2.

Batman: AA because after you catch the Joker and Riddler there is not much reason to stick around unless you like the online.

Assassin's Creed because it had very little replay value after I beat it.

I am assuming you completed these games. Sell them and treasure the memories but make new ones.

 

[EMFCRACKSHOT]

I think it comes down to this: Which games do you think you would like to play again, and which ones will you just leave to gather dust.
Of those titles, i personally would trade in Assassins Creed and Batman because i think they have the least replay value. (And as Assassins Creed will get you maybe a fiver, go with Batman. You'll get more for it)
You could make some kind of chart with the pros and cons of each game and decide which one you want to keep that way.
Besides, when you trade in your game, and a few months down the line when you decide you want to play it and you can't, i don't want you blaming me for telling you to do it

 

[Flamezdudes]

I've completed them all and i've got ME2 but don't want to trade that in. I'm in UK btw, if you start suggesting Gamestop, we don't have that.

 

[GiantRedButton]

AC and Batman don't have much replayability, so you won't miss them that much.
I'd keep Prototype. It moght be popular to hate that game, but running and flying around is always fun.
Mass effect might get allot cooler once the whole trilogy is out
also the Half life collection in the orange box is something nice to replay for nostalgia later, I think it should stay in your collection.