I am yet to see such a game. FEAR was shit. A low-quality shooter that pretended to be a horror game by making the screen flicker every now and again and showing you a silhouette of a spoooooooky little girl between each dose of blazing, generic, ball-swelling, slo-mo, headshot action.Desert Punk said:Well folks, you heard it here, any media where the protagonists fight back can no longer be classified as horror.Zhukov said:It's not horror if you can fight back.
Really though, it can be horor if you can fight back, Fear was a fairly decent horror game where you spent a lot of time fighting.
No, I would not consider any of those games to be successfully horrific. Mostly because they allow you to kill everything in your way. Funny, that.ToastiestZombie said:Did you not see that when he shot the robot the robot only stopped for like 2 seconds, and after that it ran much faster. The gun pretty much seems to be a way of seeing what's in the fog, and it has a very low frame-rate (the gun's screen). Would you consider the Silent Hill games not horror? What about the early Resident Evils, or Penumbra? Horror doesn't need to be an Amnesia clone to work.Zhukov said:Looked interesting right up until he pulled out a gun and shot something.
It's not horror if you can fight back.
The Silent Hill games had cool stories, but... actually, wait a sec, Silent Hill 2 had a cool story. SH1&3 had fucking goofy stories. I didn't find them scary though. Their monsters were downright comical, not to mention frequently glitchy.
The early Resident Evils were bad action games with shitty controls. Then you realise that you can just running past almost everything and they become jogging simulators with shitty level design. It isn't automatically scary because "OMG zombies".
Penumbra was a better attempt than most, and paved the way for the much better Amnesia. However, it suddenly stopped being much of a horror game the moment I figured out how to kill the enemies (throw a barrel to knock them over, then stun-lock them when they try to get up). From then on I was actively hunting them down and giggling at their pathetic attempts to fight back. Oh, the horror.