RPG players: good or evil

[Ushiromiya Battler]

I really hate that there's always a easily distinguishable good and bad side....
Where did all the choices go! Why can't I be real jerk, that is occasionally good? Why can't I choose the grey area?

OT: Evil first, most interesting.

 

[Son of a Mitch]

I always choose the most evil, psychotic bastard ever, because everyone I know only does the goody two-shoes options. I want to see what happens differently between our runs. And it's usually the more fun option.

 

[varulfic]

Evil is overrated in my opinion. Especially since the evil option is often just stupid, like your character is going out of his way to be an asshole even if there's no tangible reward for it. Besides that, good just feels more rewarding.

 

[LetalisK]

Good. It's almost always the more powerful option with fewest penalties. It also tends to be the easiest path, which is sad.

 

[SouthpawFencer]

Generally, I end up playing Good. For the most part, the "Evil" or "Renegade" choices often come across as "being an asshole simply to be an asshole, rather than for any compelling or interesting reason." This is especially true for dialogue.

 

[Da Orky Man]

Good by the standards of Mordin Solus. I'll always aim for the good goals, but I don't mind committing the lesser evil for the greater good. I'm the Vetinari of gaming.

 

[mrscott137]

Do anything for a greater good (murder all evil people for example) but occasionally i will save my game and rampage somewhere and reload for the sake of it.