I am someone who has only played SR3, and seen someone else play all through SR2 on youtube, i'd have to say i'd like SR3 better. Sure SR2 had a better story and gangs, but when i look at it now, it just seems a bit outdated and the minigames are just a pain, youve got so many of them and they are all just so similar. I also really like the custimization in SR3, as well is the humor in it.